Keep it totally streetable but get rid of the snap oversteer on track | FerrariChat

Keep it totally streetable but get rid of the snap oversteer on track

Discussion in '360/430' started by RotarySwingGolf, May 22, 2013.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    #1 RotarySwingGolf, May 22, 2013
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    A few weeks ago I tracked the 360 at Sebring and it was a real eye opener. All the comments over the years and reviews of the snap oversteer, twitchiness in high speed turns, etc. came to life for me. After ten years of tracking and never once having all four off, I went off twice in 30 minutes lol!

    All of my track days have been in my M3's, so this was a very different experience and challenge. In the end, I'll be a much smoother driver as this won't let me get away with things that a front engine BMW will. But, I do want to feel more comfortable with it so I feel more comfortable tracking it more often and some modifications are necessary for that.

    After talking to the dealer who runs the Challenge teams, they said pretty much everyone that tracked a 360 they had serviced or sold brought it in the next day to put a wing on it! I don't want to do a permanent deal like that. So they suggested the next best thing was to lower it and that's obviously reverseable. I want to keep the car comfortable on the street as my wife drives it so going with heavy springs, keeping it lowered all the time, etc. are not an option.

    I've looked into lowering it a little bit, my understanding is that you pretty much have to take the coilovers off to do this. If that's the case, that's fine I guess. I'm guessing this is a 2 hour-ish job and could be done while putting on the track pads?

    The dealer said this was the biggest thing to make her behave better and still be easily reversable to keep it steetable and comfortable as I don't want to keep it lowered all the time. Getting in and out of my 355 is a pita because of how low it sits and those days are behind me.

    I've read through 360Trev's stuff - pretty much ALL of it - and I was wondering how much changing the alignment would effect the oversteer when lifting off the throttle or braking on the track. I realize when I lower it, it will effect the alignment, especially the camber. Ideally, if dropping it, say, an inch would also buy me enough neg camber to be more stable on the track and then when I raise it back up when I get home it sets back to normal, then perhaps that would be the best compromise.

    Again, keep in mind I want something relatively quick and easy. I know the alignment would be a guess but has anyone else done something like this to enjoy the car more at the track and yet still have her drive as stock when you get her back home?
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  2. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    What alignment are you currently running? We're your offs because of trail braking, hitting an early apex and running out of room, or something else?
     
  3. PSk

    PSk F1 World Champ

    Nov 20, 2002
    17,673
    Tauranga, NZ
    Full Name:
    Pete
    I believe throttle control is very different between a front engined car and a mid-engined car like the F360 ... thus with some time to allow you to change habits surely this issue would be somewhat resolved?

    My point is not all cars behave the same to the same inputs and YOU need to adapt.
    Pete
     
  4. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    The first off was on 16 and came in hot, second was a spin out on 17 coming in hot and trail braking - a now known no-no in this car but something I always did in M3.

    Alignment is the factory default done at the dealer.

    PSK, looking at your profile it appears you don't own a 360, so you wouldn't understand what I'm talking about here.
     
  5. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    I'm running -2F/-2.5R with some toe in the rear... Seems that is what most folks are happy with.. Car is a bit lower than stock, but I'm not sure how much (previous owner was responsible) I can compare measurements if you want. I have only a little seat time to compare, but I've been able to control high speed traction loss and keep it moving the direction I want - 2 times above 80mph I had the rear break on me and I had time to respond.. No snap. Regardless of the setup, I think the weight balance is controllable, but smoother, and keeping the weight neutral or on the back tires in corners will keep things happier :). Traction control in sport I assume? Tires? Did you watch tire pressures?
     
  6. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    We watched tire pressures very carefully (my instructor and I - he was awesome and has 1000's of laps at Sebring) and adjusted the pressure lower mid day and that did help. I did learn how much you have to throttle steer the car and how bad it is to let off the gas mid way around - the rear would go out instantly! But when it broke loose on 17, I wasn't doing 80, I was over 140 mph going into that turn so there's not much to be done in this car at that speed when the rear gets happy. I felt awful for the little old lady who working the corner as I had the nose pointing straight at her when it started to spin. I opened up, went both feet in and let her spin into the open and all was fine.

    In my M3, it was a thousand times more predictable and could still be caught, if you even got into that situation, which was far less likely. The M3's I had (E36 and E92) let me get into some aggressive bad habits so, like I said, I'll be a smoother driver and was significantly by the end of the day (my lap times went down 18 seconds by the third session), but, this is a well known problem with this car and I'm certain some guys here have some insight.

    I did have the traction control on and Sport, although after going in around in a guy with a Scud who used to track a 360 he said to turn it off as that was one of the things that made the 360 twitchy, but I had boiled the stock brake fluid by then and my day was over.

    Tires were Pilot Sports.

    It would be great to hear from someone who has changed the alignment specs and the ride height and was able to compare the difference on the track.
     
  7. PSk

    PSk F1 World Champ

    Nov 20, 2002
    17,673
    Tauranga, NZ
    Full Name:
    Pete
    Fair comment but I did have to adapt my driving style with the last club car I built and raced.

    Good luck
    Pete
     
  8. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    Funny you say that about the brakes - I've been dealing with that, and now have a front bbk on the way.

    Would be curious what others have to say. I don't know that track at all, but 140mph corner speed is no joke...
     
  9. Michael B

    Michael B F1 Rookie
    Owner

    Apr 28, 2004
    3,762
    US of A
    Full Name:
    Michael
    Does a Stradale count?

    My mount was twitchy to the point that it felt like I was going to go off at any moment when I 1st tried it. But it never actually got this out of hand. Anyhow I made several trips to the alignment rack & finally came off of it with cornering prowess that matches the hype.

    It did take gobs of negative camber, and toe in at the rear (more than I thought it would). Its just plain impressive now.

    I can still step the rear out when pushed, but the damn thing goes where its pointed - competently.

    Get on that alignment & invest in a more track oriented tire.

    One last note. These cars roll too much (just look at your photo). I would bet on a larger set of anti-sway bars if I wanted to continue to tune my setup (but for now I am pleased).
     
  10. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    Michael - What settings did you finally settle on?
    Like I said, I'm at -2 and -2.5, and then a total of .5deg of total toe in the rear.
     
  11. djastral69

    djastral69 Formula 3
    Silver Subscribed

    Aug 6, 2007
    1,896
    Fl
    Full Name:
    David
    Can you give us a print out of what alignment was used on your car so we know where to start? Thank you
     
  12. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    The brakes were actually excellent as is with EBC Yellowstuff pads. I flushed the fluid out with some new crazy crap from Japan that the dealer had. A guy imported it for his 430C and they had a case left over. It has a higher boiling temp than Castrol SRF and was half the price so they could get rid of it!

    And I wasn't cornering at 140, just to be clear. I was at 140+ down the straight going into 17, then braking later than normal at my instructors call and was trail breaking into the turn. GPS indicated 123mph at the time it broke loose but I don't know how quickly that thing updates at those speeds.

    Michael B, thanks for this! Yes a Stradale counts, although your way ahead to start with, but I'm glad to hear you found the same thing, even with the CS. I felt exactly the same way, like it was trying to kill me and I was just constantly working to keep it on the track.

    The sway bars was something I was wondering about that 360Trev mentioned. I believe he suggested to go with the Scud bars and maybe their bushing and I don't think that would effect day to day driving too bad in a negative way. I live in FL so the roads here are quite good.

    Do you know how much camber and toe in you settled on?

    I also do think I'll pick up a set of CS wheels for a little more mechanical grip and throw some better tires on, but haven't gotten that far with it yet.
     
  13. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    #13 RotarySwingGolf, May 22, 2013
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    david, I don't have a printout unfortunately as I didn't have it done, the prev owner did the major in Toronto and had it done then.

    And yep, she rolls alright, although you don't feel much from the cockpit. I don't feel like it's just a ton of body roll throwing the car from side to side, just that the rear end wants to go out at all times because it's losing grip. In Bishop Bend, I essentially set the turn going in and don't touch it all the way through, so there is ZERO jerky input from me and I keep the throttle constant and it still feels like it is constantly trying to slip....
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  14. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan

    Ok, brakes could feel good, but your crazy fluid boiled! Sucks to get to a corner and have the pedal hit the floor. I know!

    Your spin at corner 17 sounds like you were asking a lot of the car, scrubbing a fair amount of speed some of which was after turn-in. Throw up the video if you have it!
     
  15. Michael B

    Michael B F1 Rookie
    Owner

    Apr 28, 2004
    3,762
    US of A
    Full Name:
    Michael
    Certainly,

    Looks like (have last printout here) Front= Caster 7.2 / Camber -3.1 / Toe 0 ~ Rear = Camber - 2.55 / Toe-in .20" each

    I started with F430GT recommendations & went from there until I was content (but not done yet!).

    Yeah, with that much roll the negative camber really comes into play.
     
  16. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    Sorry, the stock fluid boiled, when I got home I put the crazy Japanese stuff in so that should never happen again!

    Here's the vid of 17. Speedo indicated 140+ down this straight during the day (I wasn't looking here, I promise!, but GPS indicated lower)

    This was a mistake on both our parts (instructor and mine) and this is not what I'm trying to fix in the car, this was pilot error. This was my second session and I still didn't have a clue what to do in 17, drivers go for years and still don't know how best to handle it! I was getting so much faster through the rest of the track that he kept pushing me, which was good, but I thought that I needed to turn in more here early on. I later learned there is a ton of room to brake longer into the turn, but just didn't know that yet. There's a LOT of stuff to learn on this track.

    Because he had me brake so much later than I was used to I was unclear what to do next and when he put his hand down fast, well, my foot went down fast! All of this lead to a nice big spin out and no flat spots luckily!

    [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXr-gyinKlI]Ferrari 360 spin turn 17 sebring - YouTube[/ame]
     
  17. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    Did you reach down to change gears (manual?) right as you turned in? Almost looks like that's what upset the stability.

    I changed my fluid too, helped but didn't resolve completely for me. Hopefully you are good. I came to the conclusion, right or not, that the fronts are just a little small for my use of the car (longer braking than a more experienced driver), and hot enough to do nasty things.
     
  18. RotarySwingGolf

    RotarySwingGolf Formula Junior

    Dec 24, 2011
    490
    Florida and Idaho
    It is a manual and I would be getting ready to downshift there so that could've added to what was already a mess!

    What pads have you used? Sebring is a track that requires heavy braking after very fast straights and is hard on brakes and I only went through a half set of the yellowstuff. I've used them in the past in my M3s and they've been pretty solid and I was mashing on them with no probs except the fluid
     
  19. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    #19 cm2, May 22, 2013
    Last edited: May 22, 2013
    I'm using carbotech xp10 front xp8 rear... Was going to move up to xp10/10 or xp12/10 for better bite & consistency, but now with the larger fronts, I'm going to try xp10/10. With this setups it looked like 1/3 or 1/4 use in a track day... But that's going to vary a lot. Hopefully you can get by with new fluid, I boiled it with brand new motul rbf600... Melted the dust boots, burned the paint off of the pads, etc. Pads didn't fade much if at all.

    Downshifts can definitely benefit from some heel/toe... And without care really can jerk traction away from you...

    btw, your car looks great out there (already pretty low?)

    Sorry, just looked at my sheet. I'm at -2.5F and -2R. So, Michael is running just a little more F and R.
     
  20. Spdrcrj

    Spdrcrj Formula 3
    BANNED

    Apr 22, 2006
    1,101
    Full Name:
    Jim
    Thank you very much for posting these specs Michael. I'm going to have my CS adjusted to these specs and see how the work at Spring Mountain in Sept.

    cheers!

     
  21. Spdrcrj

    Spdrcrj Formula 3
    BANNED

    Apr 22, 2006
    1,101
    Full Name:
    Jim
    ouch, kinda harsh no? PSK was just trying to help as you make many comparisons to your M3 (another fantastic car in it's own right for sure).

    anyway....good luck brotha. Nice to see another fcar on track. :)
     
  22. F430GT

    F430GT Formula 3

    Sep 29, 2005
    1,300
    Marco Island, FL
    There are too many factors at play.

    1) How old are the tires? If older than 4 years or heat cycled out, they are not track worthy. Sebring does not forgive old tires, I have witnessed plenty of cars finished there.
    2) What is the specific tire model (there are many series of Michelin Pilot)?
    3) A 360 Modena will surely not reach 140mph before T17 at Sebring, much less with a 150-200 lbs ballast sitting as an instructor. All the speedometers in almost every Ferrari are inaccurate by a large margin. The error increases with speed, because it is proportional. For instance, a car showing 110 mph on the speedo, while indicating 100mph on the GPS will shows 220mph on speedo at 200mph.
    4) The GPS speed is very precise, from a navigation system, Harry's Lap Timer on an iPhone, and Android Phone, or a decent data acquisition system.
    5) YellowStuff pads are garbage and should never be used on a racetrack. Pagid, Endless, PFC, Carbotech, Cobalt make great track brake pads.
    6) It is good to know what kind of brake fluid was replaced in the system.

    By looking at the video, and the steering angle (almost straight), that's a very little angle to produce a spin. The car is either suffering from an ill alignment, heat cycled out tires or bump steer on the rear axle. There are no bumps at the end of the back straight entering T17, but the picture shows a lowered car, so bump steer is still a problem.

    The 360 is very easy to align, if you plan on tracking the Modena some more, the car will need stiffer springs, bigger front brakes, and brake cooling ducts. I like the Pagid RS19 or RS29 pads for combined street/track use, I even use RS19 on my SUV (better for towing when brakes are critical).

    For track use, I would get a 2nd set of wheels and fit tires that are suitable for track use, many affordable options available. This will eliminate the tire age problem.

    Florida weather (hot and humid) presents high stress on the engine, transmission, brakes, clutch, as things run hot in here. With decent driving skills, the stock Modena brakes won't tolerate Sebring not even with good pads, good brake fluid, and brake cooling ducts. This car really needs a big brake kit.

    No idea on what lap times the HLT iPhone app was reporting, but based on the 2:34 by the end of the straight barrier between T16 and T17, and the actual top speed shown (126mph which is decent for a 360 Modena on pure street tires), the lap times must have been in the 2:45 to 3:00 minutes range. At this pace, there is no need to change the brake system, just add cooling ducts, good brake pads, good brake fluid.

    360/F430/16M/Scuderia/Stradale share a lot of the basic suspension geometry, and they have similar weight distribution.

    Feel free to stop by an alignment shop (GoodYear store), and ask them to connect the sensors from their alignment equipment, and get a read-out of the alignment the car has right now, I bet it is messed up badly. Get a print out from them. It should cost no more than $50 (don't do the alignment, just get the reading in print). Also measure the ride height from the front and the back on the side rocker panels (4 corners), I can extrapolate to height from the suspension measuring points if you provide the tire model, their tread depth, and inflate them in between 30psi and 40psi.

    The measuring point for the suspension is easy to reach when the car is on the alignment bridge (Front is chassis from the back section of the lower control arm, Rear is chassis from the front section of the lower control arm).

    A friend went emotional and brought his Stradale to a racetrack, despite of my advice to change the tires, brake pads, brake fluid, alignment, ride height and corner weights. He totaled the car, the car did a snap oversteer on turn exit and hit the wall, he is an experienced track driver.

    The expenses are pretty low to make a Modena track-friendly, and a 360 Modena with a manual transmission must be one of the must fun cars (not the fastest) out there.
     
  23. F430GT

    F430GT Formula 3

    Sep 29, 2005
    1,300
    Marco Island, FL
    The critical alignment setting in these cars (360/F430) is rear toe. Be sure you're using 0.25 degrees toe-in per rear corner (0.50 degrees total).

    Some shops use minutes to measure angles, rather than degrees.

    20' (20 minutes) per rear corner is too much toe-in.

    60' = 1 degree
    20' = 0.333 degrees (it would put total toe-in to 0.67 degrees, way too much).

    To achieve 0.25 degrees per rear wheel, (15' per rear wheel), you can also use millimeters. 4mm total toe-in will produce the 0.50 degrees total toe-in.

    Front toe is good at zero, or just a little toe-in for comfort on the streets and high speed (0.10 degrees per wheel), or a little toe-out for autoX and twisty race tracks (0.10 degrees per wheel).

    Camber is determined by the tires used. -2.0 degrees all-around is fine for street tires. -2.5 degrees all-around is fine for combined track/street use. These are initial settings, as camber needs to be fine tuned for the tires being used, car weight, driving skills, racetrack, etc, many factors.
     
  24. F430GT

    F430GT Formula 3

    Sep 29, 2005
    1,300
    Marco Island, FL
    The alignment is pretty decent. I would recommend you:

    Front: -2.5 camber, 0 toe
    Rear: -2.5 degrees camber, 0.50 degrees total toe-in (0.25 degrees per corner)

    From the front and rear ride height measuring points: 120mm front, 140mm rear. If you can run stiffer springs, then set it down to 110mm front and 130mm rear. Below this ride height, or running this ride height with racing tires, the car will hit the bump stops, and handling suffers badly when you ride the bump stops.
     
  25. cm2

    cm2 Formula 3

    Sep 26, 2012
    1,451
    SF Bay
    Full Name:
    Nathan

    Thanks, I actually am at -2.5F and -2R. I had it switched around. And the toe you suggest. What are the measuring points you mention?

    Also, I really am curious what solution you've seen/used for brake ducts. (Like really interested in detail!!) And how the challenge carbon deal might bolt up and work or not.
     

Share This Page