Interesting read: Driver-by-driver review & rating for 2014 | FerrariChat

Interesting read: Driver-by-driver review & rating for 2014

Discussion in 'F1' started by freshmeat, Dec 2, 2014.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. freshmeat

    freshmeat F1 Veteran

    Aug 30, 2011
    7,257
    #1 freshmeat, Dec 2, 2014
    Last edited: Dec 2, 2014
    I enjoyed it, perhaps other folks might too:
    The 2014 driver-by-driver review: Every driver's season reviewed and rated | Features & Experts | Sky Sports Formula 1


    Ricci
    --------------

    Championship position –3rd, 238 points; Best result – 1st (x3)

    Without doubt Daniel Ricciardo was the standout performer of 2014 after a remarkable debut season at Red Bull. Don’t be fooled by the smiley exterior, the 25-year-old proved to be a tough competitor on track. He comprehensively outperformed his team-mate and reigning World Champion Sebastian Vettel, winning the qualifying battle 12-7 and the race head-to-head 14-5. Indeed perhaps those performances played a part in Vettel leaving for Ferrari a year before his Red Bull contract expired.

    Ricciardo finished the season as the only non-Mercedes driver to win a race and was always seemingly the man on hand to capitalise when Lewis Hamilton or Nico Rosberg hit strife. That ability would help him pick up three victories, including one in Hungary which the Australian feels was a straight fight.

    This really was the season that Ricciardo came of age and established himself as a top F1 driver and as a man capable of delivering Australia’s first world title since Alan Jones in 1980. 2015 will represent a different challenge as he becomes de-facto team leader, but there is no reason to think he cannot build on this year and continue to be a front-runner. WE

    2014 rating: 9/10



    seb
    --------------

    Championship position – 5th, 167 points; Best result – 2nd

    What was it that Fernando Alonso said of the recently-crowned quadruple World Champion last November? Ahh, yes: “When he will have a car like the others, if he wins, he will have a great recognition and be one of the legends in F1. When one day he has a car like the others and he is fourth, fifth, seventh, these four titles will be bad news for him because people will take these four titles even in a worse manner than they are doing now. So there are interesting times for Sebastian coming."

    How resonant those words sound a year later in the wake of Sebastian’s defeat to Daniel Ricciardo, his average finishing position of fifth, and the German’s struggles – bordering on inability – to master the rear-end instability of the RB10. Which isn’t to say that his four titles, in the RB10’s aerodynamically pitch-perfect successors, should be considered hollow triumphs, but there’s no denying that one skill every great sportsman possesses is the ability to adapt. It’s a test which Sebastian ignominiously failed in 2014.

    In total, there were just four podium visits, and none at all to the top step where Ricciardo stood on three different occasions. But for the German’s bad luck on a few occasions, it could be termed a thrashing. Still, if you think 2014 has been a bad year for Vettel’s reputation because of Ricciardo’s exploits, spare a thought for what it did for Mark Webber’s and try not to wince. PG

    2014 rating: 5/10



    alonso
    --------------

    Championship position – 6th, 161 points; Best result – 2nd

    So, the partnership that was meant to dominate F1 has crumbled, two years early and without a single World Championship title to its name. That Alonso leaves Ferrari with the same status as when he arrived – a ‘mere’ two-time world champion – certainly reflects a case of Ferrari having failed Fernando, rather than Fernando failing Ferrari. Such a reality was never more the case than in 2014, with the team’s hope that a move away from an aerodynamic-dominant formula would present the springboard from which to return to winning ways proving to be as flawed as the F14 T they created to suit the new engine regulations. As a result Fernando graced the podium just twice all season – and not once the top step.

    Not that such an unusually low-key run of results harmed Alonso’s standing in the sport – in fact the two podiums he did achieve, particularly his gallant tyre preservation run to second place in Hungary, only served to increase his widespread reputation as the best all-round driver in F1. The fact the Spaniard also turned what had been an eagerly-anticipated intra-team battle with Raikkonen into an effective no-contest in his favour only added further fuel to the feeling that he was still operating at his peak, even if Ferrari quite definitely weren’t. That he’s heading back to McLaren of all places shows how exasperating his time at Maranello became. JG

    2014 rating: 8/10



    --------------

    loldonado got 3/10...what utter nonsense, he deserves maybe half a point, lol. enjoy.
     
  2. spirot

    spirot F1 World Champ

    Dec 12, 2005
    14,532
    Atlanta
    Full Name:
    Tom Spiro
    I would agree with the assesments. Maybe Vettle's was a bit harsh, but you have to look at it - he was beaten fair and square by Ricciardo.

    I think Mercedes was so dominant that its hard to really assess Hamilton and Rosberg, but in the end they won it all.
     
  3. intrepidcva11

    intrepidcva11 F1 Rookie
    Rossa Subscribed

    Jan 12, 2009
    3,215
    Saratoga Springs NY
    Full Name:
    Seth
    IMHO, not harsh at all, spirot. Here's what I wrote last November 2013 in the aftermath of Vettel's fourth consecutive WDC when almost everyone was comparing him to Michael:


    Despite his four consecutive WDC's, I am far from persuaded that Sebastien is the 'head-and-shoulders-better' driver that many believe he is. To me it is absolutely clear that for four years he was driving a car that was indeed 'head-and-shoulders' better than any other car on the grid.

    Mark Webber, a journeyman middle of the pack driver his entire pre-Red Bull career, suddenly is on the front row almost every race? Webber, a really good guy but only a fair driver, begins in F1 in 2002 age 26, racing for such mediocre teams as Minardi and Jaguar. When he joins Williams he is a little bit better than middle pack but nowhere near a consistent challenger. Then he joins RedBull in 2007 at age 31 still racing just above middle of pack for a couple of years as the car is improving.

    Comes 2009 and Sebastien Vettel joins Red Bull and a dramatically improved car. At age 33 after racing in F1 for seven years Mark finally wins his first F1 race, the 2009 German GP and his second, the Brazilian G.P. Comes 2010 and an utterly dominant Red Bull car and what have we in Mark Webber? - four F! wins, five poles (OVER VETTEL!) AND TEN PODIUMS!! He actually led the drivers' championship after Monaco and could have been 2010 World Champion if he had won the last race at Abu Dhabi and Fernando had finished no higher than third! This from a guy who had never been on the podium before!

    Sebastien is an outstanding driver, don't misunderstand me, as are at least a half dozen others, Fernando (to me the best driving today), Lewis, Nico, Kimi, maybe Daniel. But since 2009 and until this year F1 has been all about the Red Bull car. So I can do without Seb in my Ferraris. I want Fred to win a couple of WDC's in red and I also think the Scuderia has a potentially sensational young development driver coming up. [our lamented Jules Bianchi]



    And Vettel's miserable comparison with teammate Daniel Ricciardo this season drives the point home. Seb is very good, he has not yet shown that he's great, and I continue to have my serious reservations.
     
  4. RallyeChris

    RallyeChris Formula Junior

    Nov 30, 2012
    553
    Northport, NY
    Full Name:
    S.C.Conigliaro
    And you continue to quote yourself in just about every thread you enter. Get over yourself... Seriously.
     
  5. intrepidcva11

    intrepidcva11 F1 Rookie
    Rossa Subscribed

    Jan 12, 2009
    3,215
    Saratoga Springs NY
    Full Name:
    Seth
    Point taken, S.C.
     

Share This Page