Any recomendations on a car insurance company?

Don't know where to post this, so I am putting it here. Sorry if it is not in the correct forum. Are there any recommendations as to a good insurance company for a Ferrari, or any other high end car for that matter. Anytime I google an insurance company, it inevitably comes back with 2 stars or something. I have come to realize that people who are happy with their insurance companies probably don't post reviews, it is the unhappy people who post. Either that, or all insurance companies are evil bloodsucking parasites - hmmm.

My insurance company won't insure a Ferrari because it is an exotic car. They recommended American Modern Insurance. The price is about half that of Progressive, but I have never heard of this company. Does anyone know anything about American Modern? Can anyone recommend a good insurance company that has good customer service and that won't gouge me? Thanks.

 

Thank you for your responses. Will check them out and see what they say.

 

So, just an update. Did an online quote last night at Hagerty insurance (as well as 2 others). Price was about twice of American Modern, but I see them recommended, so I figured I would call and talk to them. Called the guy today. It felt like an inquisition (reminds me of Monty Python)! Anyways, he asked me a bunch of questions. One of them was that I needed to have a car less than 6 years old. I informed him that I had 3 other cars, and this would definitely not be a daily driver - just for weekends and pleasure and such. I told him that I can't even see me putting 3,000 miles on it per year. Then he asked if I was part of a car club. I said, we don't have one here, but a few of us get together with our cars and have coffee, B.S., and look at each other's cars and such about once every 2 months or so. He said, well, that is splitting hairs, so they may not be able to insure me. Mind you, I have never had an accident (cross fingers), and haven't had a speeding ticket in 10 years! I told him that he must be joking. He said I can file an application and see what happens. I said I haven't bought the car yet, just wanted to be ready for when I did. Unbelievable. All this just for car insurance. So, I then called American Modern and it was way easier. Just amazing!!!

 

Yea, about twice that of American Modern. I will probably go with AM unless anyone has bad things to say about them.

 

Let me know what they say. I am not insured with them, so I don't know what their customer service is like if you have a claim. I have my car and home insurance with Ameriprise through Costco. I called them, and they said that they do not insure Ferraris, but they gave me a quote with AM, and it was about half of Geico and Hagerty for the same coverage. I asked the Costco rep if AM was A+, and she said that all the insurance companies that Costco works with are A+. I don't know if the price was low because I am with Costco and have my home and other cars insured with them, or if they are always lower. I had Costco check with Geico, and they were about twice as much. Guess it doesn't hurt to take a look. Let me know what you find out.

 

Did they ask you about being a member of a car club and so on? They seem to make it difficult to "get in." Also, parkerfe, what are your thoughts on American Modern Insurance? Thanks.