Modern 1/2 Ton Truck Towing

At track days, I see some pretty big as trailers getting towed by the ecoboosts.

These new trucks have all the nannies which I think helps.

I've never driven an ecoboosts but I bet it tows better than my excursion

 

Lash,

I use our '16 Cadillac Escalade ESV to tow my daughters horse trailer, it will take up to 8300lbs. With the 6.2L V8 and the heavy duty tow package and heavy duty differential, plus 8 speed transmission it has no problem making the haul. Its really a non-issue, plus you get more interior space with the SUV vs Truck. The GMC 1500 Denaili has everything the Yukon XL Denaili has, same with the Cadillac and the Cadillac comes with 22", very smooth.

Nate let me use his trailer to tow my Ferrari back from Chicago in '06 and we used our Yukon XL and it did fine, just no comparison to the new trucks/SUV at that size.

When we get her a "goose-neck" trailer I will move up to the 2500 truck.

 

The newer trucks pull just fine. Stop better, have built in safety systems. But it depends on your use for me. Near max weight periodically, like a few camping trips locally each year with a camper or short trips to the track or water with a car hauler or boat, you'll be fine.
Start making longer trips or much more frequent trips and I would step up. A little overkill can add some safety. I've never owned anything bigger than a half ton. Few times I've maxed it out have been fine, but not fun. Have been towing a 22' center console for the last 15 years. 1997 F150,2001 F150, 2004 F150, 2013 F150. And an Expediton. Expy was fine, but you know it's there. The 97 was a V6, and it piled fine, but wasn't great. Each truck got better after that. The '13 is like a completely different class of truck for towing.

 

I have a 2016 Silverado double cab.

With a brake controller I have pulled around 10k lbs with it.

The truck didn't seem to have any problems.

 

Was looking at tundras, as I like toyotas. But every business owner seems to go ford... Must be a reason?

 

My wife's 2014 1500 Denali pulled my track car and enclosed trailer (7500ish lb) halfway across the US and to a handful of track days just fine, but it could have been better - especially up and down mountains. Just bought a 17 Duramax and it is nice - quiet, quick, smooth - big step up from our 4 previous Duramax pickups. Thought we'd try a 1500 for our last one and made a mistake - diesels cost a few grand more but get $10k+ more on resale. Unless you have a lack of access to diesel, it just doesn't make sense to get a gasser - at least in the GM truck line.

 

Last week I towed a friends two car enclosed trailer with his 2016 Z71 Silverado 4x4 quad cab fully loaded down with two racecars etc. right off the bumper. I was absolutely impressed with the highway ability at 70-75 MPH. No it was not a great passing slow traffic rig, but hills, driving along with traffic, normal pulling away from stop lights was a pleasure. And the damn thing was quiet like my S-Class Benz at speed. I was shocked. My favorite part? The thing never shifted. It sat at 2100RPM and just tugged along with that two car like it was a single car open trailer. I hate it when a rig gear hunts every time a head-win hits them. This rig did not.

I am a Mopar / Ram guy but was really pleased with this basic V8 gas Chevrolet.

 

Interesting.

So, what's a 'head-win'?

Sorry for the ignorance.

 

Yes thank you Rob. Head Wind.

The two race cars were about 6000... Tools, pit-scooter and a two car enclosed? Maybe 5000 more? So I was at say 11k with a 1500 Z71 with nothing but a regular below the bumper hitch. No load levelers, no anti sway, nothing. Impressed the hell outta me.

 

OK... headwind.

 

The newest trucks are SAE J2807 rated, meaning that they all can handle what they're rated for without getting real hairy. That Dam Towing Test: New SAE Trailering Standards Explained - Tech Dept. - Car and Driver

I'd pick a new half ton over a 10 year old 3/4 or 1 ton if the half ton is rated for it. Compared to the trucks from 10 years ago, they're leaps and bounds better vehicles.

At least some of the new half tons with electric power steering have crosswind stabilization. I cannot personally vouch for the benefits of such a system.

 

I can attest to Tundras.....I have an 08 that is a workhorse that has pulled 11k lbs several times, no drama. Has 210k miles on the original engine and trans, runs good as new

 

I've watched a bunch of those videos, "The Fast Lane Truck" is the channel name on YT.

https://www.youtube.com/user/tflcar

A few thoughts:

- The tow ratings are massaged by lawyers. So you know they are sand bagging the numbers to avoid lawsuits, product liability, warranty claims, etc (yet still keep up with the competition)...and protect against cannibalizing the their heavy duty product lines.

- It's not all about sheer HP/TRQ. Wheelbase and rear overhang are a couple of things that people don't really think about when considering a tow vehicle but they should! Especially with SUVs, where wheelbase (longer is better) can vary quite dramatically. Any 1/2 ton truck is going to have sufficient wheelbase as to not end up with the "tail wagging the dog" (precursor to jack-knifing) in most situations.

- Consider weight distribution hitch and anti-sway bar. Might be overkill depending on your scenario but they make a world of difference.

- Wind and 18-wheelers are your enemy and will still create a white knuckle moment now and again.

What are you planning to tow anyway??

 

Having a bit of experience towing with both F350s of a slightly newer vintage than you're looking at, and vehicles with 3.5L Ecoboost, I'd go with the newer F150. Or Expedition if that form factor works better for you. "Available late 2017".
I also own a truck of that older vintage, and I love it, but I'm constantly reminded that the new trucks do every single thing better than Ol' Rusty.

It's mostly about the comfort and convenience. 20 years of automotive development are all working to make the seat time more pleasant. Put on some Sirius radio, set the radar cruise control, turn on the massaging seat and turn on the lane keeping assist... Just in case it all becomes too comfortable! And that J2807 certification means it will pull what it's rated at easily. I'd bet that 3.5L EcoBoost will outpull that old 7.3L, too (fuel costs will be higher, they're thirsty when working hard).

 

Lowest cost bidder. You can get a 2017 ecoboost 4x4 extra cab truck for 31k.

 

I got a Tundra crewcab with the big V8 4wd etc. It was the lowest bidder by far at the time. 14k 3 year single pay lease.

Of all the trucks I drove the Ford was the most comfortable/limo like, and steered the best, but with any decent spec was significantly more.

I took the advice of a neighbour and got a crew cab, which was really good advice if you think of using the truck for any other purpose, its nice to be able to travel with your friends or family comfortably.

The Tundra feels anvil tough, tows great, has lots of room and I am very happy with it.
Budget unlimited, ford is the top pick and I tried them all.