2007 911 turbo or 2011 911 turbo S

which would you buy and why
price gap is about 20k

07 is tip 11k miles
11 is pdk 20k miles

 

I've had a '03 996 Turbo Tiptronic, a '10 997 Turbo PDK, and just got a '17 991.2 Turbo S PDK. My recommendation is to definitely go with '11 PDK. It's light years better than the Tiptronic. Drive the cars back to back and I think you'll agree.

 

thanks John
appreciate your input....leaning towards the .2 pdk

 

I've had a number of Porsche's through the years. That plus hearing from other people time and time again being the PDK is in another world better. The Tip is not much fun at all.
Manual>PDK>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Tiptronic. The $20k extra will come back to help when you sell the car as well. Plus being that much newer. You'll recoup a lot of that money when you sell or trade it in later on.

 

thx Jim......agreed

 

Turbo S with PDK all the way.

The PDK transmission is amaking. I have had a GT3, GT3 RS and now have a Targa GTS 4 - all with PDK. I also have an F12 and I hate to say it, but PDK is noticably superior to Ferrari's dual cluch.

 

Thanks Steve for the input

Chas

 

+1

Tiptronic is deal breaker on sports car. Pdk all the way

 

Launch control and more hp and 4 years newer. Worth $20k.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

yup yup

 

Why not manual ?? If it's an everyday car, go PDK... If it a weekend toy, go manual !!

 

2007 also has the weak IMS bearing and it's not serviceable.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using Tapatalk

 

hard to find turbo s in white

 

No IMS problems on the Mezger.

For 20k difference get the 2011

 

I have an 08 and like it a lot, but its a stick. I would definitely take the PDK model.

 

I have a '08 turbo with tip and have driven '11 4S with PDK - no comparison PDK is way better. The 996/997 turbos do not have any IMS issues different engind than Carreras.

But likely you can get a much better deal on the 07 turbo with tip if there is a budget issue. Otherwise no question about the PDK being the better car. Also the '11 997.2 has direct injection and better electronics - Nav bluetooth etc. Would only get the 07 if the budget is main consideration.

 

The last 997 turbos in stick will become collector items. Get one now.

Just say NO to Tiptronics.

 

No issues on IMS with any of the Turbo cars because it is a Metzger engine. IMS also corrected for the 997 series.

 

Yeah that was my bad, obviously. Sorry.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using Tapatalk

 

I endorse this prediction.
I'm keeping my 2007 TT manual not for the potential resale vale but because it's such an outstanding DD
Super fun, sexy and reliable
Only caveat is coolant hose failure can make a good day bad.

 

As said previously the 996/997 Turbos don't have IMS issues. It was the Carreras which had IMS issues which were corrected in the 997.2. The gen one Carrera's still had issues.

 

Odd, no one has mentioned the most important aspect, the PDK allows the car to stay on boost in between shifts.....THATS how all the sub 3 second runs are possible.

 

I have been noodling buying a pre-owned 2011-2015 911 turbo - there is ebay, autotrader, forums and then the dealers... I like a good value but also don't want a car that has been used and abused.

What do you think is the best way to find what I am looking for? Just get a PPI and hope for the best? Looking for some direction as I hate to pay retail at the dealership.

The turbo will have under 15k miles if that matters.

 

do all the necessary research, ppi, etc for a private sale or pay more to dealer for a cpo with warranty. not much else to chose from

excellence magazine has good buyers guides you could check for reference too

 

I would be inclined to stay away from EBay unless a Pdealer owned car since you can almost never do any real good research on the car and often hard to get a PPI. Usually you can’t actually see the car which is a personal prerequisite for me buying used.

The site I like best cars.com "advanced search" as you can narrow the alternatives to pretty much exactly what you want better than other sites and they seem to have more listings IMO. Currently 207 nationwide with 30k miles or less listed at cars.com under $150k thru 2011-'15 and 248 w/ no price limit. There are less "good deals" on turbos - just less made and individual owners of turbos usually don't have to sell car in any time frame otherwise they would have traded them in for the replacement car. Most cars are either black, white silver or grey, a few are Guards Red. Every other color is not available in any kind of numbers.

Also some dealers seem to make a market in turbos more than the smaller Pcar dealers. (Rusnak in Thousand Oaks, CA tends to be such a dealer) I would not overlook dealers as they have some of the best examples and are often CPO, nothing wrong in paying retail if you get exactly what you want. As opposed to getting a deal on something close but doesn’t check all the boxes. Besides all dealers negotiate just don’t get emotionally involved with any one car. Also I would expand the mileage to 30k rather than 15k more cars available and you are a little more likely to find a better deal. 30k is still pretty low annual mileage for a 2011/12.

Finally go to your local PCA for C&C and ask around you just might find a jewel that hasn’t yet hit the market. Also Panorama magazine (PCA’s monthly) always has a turbos for sale section and the membership person at the meeting may have extra magazines available for prospective members. My wife usually has a few at our C&C meetings. Good luck hunting.