Restaurant Advice Playaz

Macellaria
48 Gansevoort St
New York, NY 10014
Cross Street: Between Greenwich Street and Washington Street
Phone: (212) 741-2555
Fax: (212) 741-0845
http://macelleria.citysearch.com/?cslink=
~Rustic Italian, Specializing in Steak~

The Harrison
355 Greenwich St
New York, NY 10013-2844
Cross Street: Harrison Street
Phone: (212) 274-9310
~Amazing American~ JP favorite

Scalini Fedeli
165 Duane St
New York, NY 10013
Cross Street: Hudson Street
Phone: (212) 528-0400
~Amazing Italian~ another JP favorite, great ambience

Sosa Borella
460 Greenwich St
New York, NY 10013-1760
Cross Street: Between Watts Street and Debrosses Street
Phone: (212) 431-5093
~Tasty Argentinean~ Their steak is great.

I'm done...happy 23rd!

 

Wolfgang's Steakhouse.

Best steak in Manhattan; it's almost a Peter Luger!

It's on The northwest corner of 33rd and Park Avenue.

phone (212) 889-3369

 

Steak:

V in the Time Warner Center is New School
Gallaghers on 51st (I think) is Old School
Dylan Prime is Hipster
The Palm on 50th is a great standard

Seafood:

Fresh on Reade Street is THE BEST!!!

 

Hey Emil--

I believe Manute's last name does not have an "e" in it.

 

Steak: Malloney Porcelli in Midtown wins my vote. (You can also go to Rothman's which is owned by a friend of mine)

 

I also heard that KFC has pretty good mash and chicken...hehee (I couldn't resist)

 

no one likes Bryant and Cooper's? or am I just 8th man down the line on this one

 

Too "old school" for me. Great food, though, I just like the eye candy better at Dylan and V.

 

all same focking shiet.
luger, brian cooper, rothman, palm, uncle jack's ... dats pretty much as good as steak gets, no difference food wise to me. u want the new spot with vibe u prolly can go to v in aol building.

 

Does anyone know what movie Gallagher's Steakhouse (Esp The Trophy Room) is famous for. An important event took place there.

 

I don't think any of the city steak houses compares to Luger's; the only one that is actually better is in Briarcliff, up in Westchester.

 

You are dead on...Luger's is still the best, but you need to know how to order so your not in and out in 60 min. And don't forget your PL Credit Card or lots of cash.

 

i dont think Luger's (Brooklyn or LI one) is that great. it's OVERRATED for my taste buds.

 

Luger's, the best. If you want to stay in Manhattan, Gallagher's is a close 2nd. Scalini Fedeli is amazing, nice place, great food, but the menu is probably a little too continental for what it sounds like your Dad really likes.

 

Gallaghers DEFINES old school. Union waiters? WTF is that!

Been to Masa but never have had to pay. It's good, over rated but good...

 

there is no best, luger is same as the other places, might be different but no better. personally i will go to other places before luger.

 

very good new steakhouse: BLT Steak.
great parking across the street at the Four Seasons.

 

the striphouse in the city. the best steak you will find. 13 west 12th st. everyone i have brought there in the past year have gone back several times...

 

I forgot about the Striphouse! It is a AWESOME PLACE!

 

Nobody likes Del Friscos ?

If find it quite ok....

Also, give a look at Meghu. It's much better than what you can eat in Japan.
And less expensive than Massa. Though i'll try it out as well next time in NYC.

 

Yep, Del Frisco's is good. Problem is that there is no shortage of good steakhouses in NYC.

For something different yet safe for traditional meat lovers is Churrascaria Plataforma on 49th between 8th and 9th. Fantastic Brazilian grill house.

John

 

The one down in Tribeca (Same Owners) has THE hottest hostess. EVER.

Where'd you decide to go??