Request for help with TR ignition problem (I think?) | FerrariChat

Request for help with TR ignition problem (I think?)

Discussion in 'Technical Q&A' started by Steve Magnusson, Aug 8, 2007.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    #1 Steve Magnusson, Aug 8, 2007
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    Wondering (and hoping) if someone out there with a TR or a 412 could make some AC voltage measurement coming from their Flywheel RPM Sensor (white connector) for comparison to my results. My "symptom" is:

    1. At cold start-up, I get ~2.1 VAC at idle, and things run OK (the "spec" is 2.0 VAC minimum),

    2. When the coolant heats up to 150~160 deg F, the system transitions to running closed-loop with the O2 sensors, but the Flywheel RPM Sensor voltage has drooped down to 1.8~1.9 VAC at idle; however, things still run OKish,

    3. After a few more minutes of warm-running, the Flywheel RPM Sensor voltage droops down further to ~1.7 VAC at idle, and it starts to get small, erratically-timed "misses" on both banks (although all plugs in both banks seem to be firing).

    4. In all cases, as the RPM is increased, the Flywheel RPM Sensor output increases by something like 0.2~0.5 VAC.

    I replaced the RPM Sensor, but get the same results. I also measured the spacing from the RPM Sensor to the Flywheel teeth, and it is a little large (0.8~0.9 mm on both the new and old RPM Sensor -- spec is 0.5~0.7 mm), but this is not so easy to decrease (and it hasn’t changed so it was working for 16 years at that spacing). So before trying to decrease the spacing, I wanted to see if I was even in the ballpark – i.e., if a “normal” output is something like 5 VAC or more, I would be less hopeful that a 0.1~0.2 mm change would make a real difference.

    The first jpeg below shows how to make this measurement (on a TR) at the white 2-pin connector for the Flywheel RPM Sensor -- of course, you need to add some sort of “jumpers” to have a place to attach the voltmeter leads but still keep the connections working. The second jpeg shows how to make this measurement using the 25-pin factory breakout box on a TR – you would measure between pins 3 & 16 (on either a TR or 412 -- the voltmeter lead positions in the jpeg don’t necessarily show this).

    Alternatively, if someone in the US has a used/working MED 120B or MED 120B/D ignition ECU, I’d be glad to “rent” it for $100 (and pay for the shipping both ways). I’m not even sure that this Flywheel RPM Sensor stuff is the real problem, but it’s the only thing that I can find wrong with the system (all other tests on Diagnosis Sheet N. 1 are OK) – and I don’t want to needlessly waste a few thousand $ on a new ignition ECU.

    Please let me know if you can help.
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  2. tbakowsky

    tbakowsky Two Time F1 World Champ
    Consultant Professional Ferrari Technician

    Sep 18, 2002
    20,042
    The Cold North
    Full Name:
    Tom
    Ya know what funny?? I'm battling the same type of issue with a Mondial 8 right now in the shop. I have replaced the crank sensors (3) and have gone as far to remove the clutch and fly wheel to look for missing teeth in the ring gear.

    My issue is this: Start the car cold, runs wonderful..revs excellent. Allow car to warm up. Once the car warms up I get intermittent tach signal from the crank sensor (sensor is new), which obviously effects how the car runs. Some times I will loose a bank completely, or other times each coil will miss fire causing really odd running. I have swapped the digiplex units around, but the problem remains the same.

    I have checked all the wiring but the problem remains the OL readings from the tech sensor intermittently, even going directly to the sensor with an ohm meter.
     
  3. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    Glad you can commisserate with me -- but I still want TR help ;)

    By "OL" above do you mean that sometimes you get an infinite resistance measurement of the new (unplugged) Flywheel RPM sensor or that you are making an operational AC voltage measurement of the Flywheel RPM Sensor and sometimes your multimeter flashes "OL"? One thing you might try (rather than swapping Digiplex units) is to just unplug each of the Digiplex units separately and see if it will run smoothly on 4 cylinders. Since they share the Flywheel RPM signal, if one of the Digiplex units is doing a bad thing on the RPM line, swapping will really have no effect -- just a thought.

    (Even though I'm not sure if they use the exact same sensor) What is the AC voltage reading from that Mondial8 Flywheel RPM sensor at idle (when it's working)?
     
  4. eulk328

    eulk328 F1 Rookie

    Feb 18, 2005
    2,800
    Full Name:
    F683
    You wrote that after warm-up you get "erratically-timed "misses""...... how do you mean? You said the plugs seem to be firing so when you say misses do you mean an erratic reading on the voltmeter?

    Is there actually a problem with your engine missing or being low on power etc.? I mean if it is running well I would not worry about the output not being exactly 2.0vac or above.

    I don't know if you did your test just the way it is set up in your photo but one of my concerns would be getting the unshielded connections (where you connected the jumper wires) farther away from the high voltage jumping around in the distributor cap. I'm not sure if the rpm sensor cable is shielded (I would think so). If it is then you're not doing any favors to your test by having the bare jumper wire connections where they are. Might not make any difference but....

    In any case, reading your post, you seem to know what you're doing. It would be nice if you could borrow an O-scope from someone to view the waveform to get a better idea of what's going on. Then you would also want some type of reference waveform to compare it to.

    Erich

     
  5. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    Thanks for the response (my first message was getting sort of lengthy, but I've got a lot more horrible details if you are interested ;)). The slight erratic miss is evident as "puffing" at the tailpipes (I have a Tubi silencer so the two bank's exhaust streams are completely separated) and a short sudden drop (that recovers) in the O2 sensor output voltages when at idle (super-imposed over the normal closed-loop wandering). The more serious operational problems are:

    1. pulling away from a stop in a normal manner has some slight hesitation and just sounds "flat" and feels "off",

    2. higher RPM feels somewhat better, but power seems off (maybe 10~20%?), and if pushed, even normally/moderately, will overheat the cats.

    Your point about x-talk from the secondary is well-taken -- I even have to unclip the longer spark plug wires from the routing looms to prevent multiple triggering when using my timing light on those wires. I do have an oscilloscope -- the jpeg was more trying to illustrate how to make the connections. I didn't notice any significant noise or instabilities in the signal when using either the oscilloscope or multimeter, and they seemed to agree -- i.e., the oscilloscope showed roughly a 4~5V p-p sine wave and the multimeter ~2 VAC (and they both "drooped" together, and I think some drooping makes sense -- alternator voltage being highest after cold start-up, clutch housing expanding away from Flywheel, etc.). I also looked at the primary coil waveform and it seemed like, although cyl #1 firing was consistent wrt the flywheel, other firing events in the sequence had more jitter than was physically possible (and more jitter corresponded to the audible puffing at idle).

    Your 328 uses a very similar ignition architechture to the TR/412 -- could you measure your Flywheel RPM sensor output? One thing I'm starting to wonder is if the Flywheel RPM Sensor output waveform should be more of a square wave rather than a sine wave -- TIA...
     
  6. eulk328

    eulk328 F1 Rookie

    Feb 18, 2005
    2,800
    Full Name:
    F683
    Hi Steve,

    Have you eliminated fueling as a cause of the problems? Are your plug wires in really good shape (electrically)?
    Since you're having problems during normal driving also (higher rpms) it would probably be easier to troubleshoot on a rolling road.

    Do you mean you're seeing "glitches" with a scope hooked up to the O2 sensors? (where the voltage just drops away completely) My car is a Swiss market version. It had a cat. but no O2 sensor and of course no frequency valve so there's no feedback like with yours.

    I'm not able to measure the output of my sensors because I'm doing a major now and installing an Electromotive XDI 2. I would tend to think you should see more of a square wave rather than a sine wave since you want to be counting events rather than a specific voltage at a certain point in time. Are you seeing more of a sine wave than square wave?

    Not sure what you meant when you wrote "more jitter than was physically possible." Can you expand on that? What type of jitter is it... pulse position, amplitute etc.?

    Maybe "NoDoubt" has some input here?? He seems like a hard-core electronics type.

    Have you considered going to an Electromotive or other ignition system? It would eliminate a lot of problem areas and give you some adjustability.

    Erich


     
  7. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    #7 Steve Magnusson, Aug 9, 2007
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    Yes, I've already thrown everything but the kitchen sink at the fuel side -- rebuild FDs, new injector set, all pressure/flow measurements OK -- I even measured the actual fuel volume coming from the individual injectors at several airflow plate openings. On the ignition side -- fresh plugs, new extenders, new caps/rotors, repierced the wires (which had been previously replaced and measured OK), and confirmed each coil/power module is firing the appropriate number of times (just some not at consistent times).

    It's not really a "glitch" in the O2 sensor signal -- it's more of a (lean) "dip" -- like a (single) slug of the unburned, or partially burned, intake charge passing by the O2 sensor.

    By "more jitter than physically possible" I mean the time jitter in some of the primary side firing events corresponds to an angular amount that the flywheel couldn't really be varying by for each subsequent revolution (based on the audible quasi-steady idle).

    You said it well with "some type of reference waveform to compare it to". I'll expand my request -- can anyone with a TR/412/328/308QV/308i/Mondial please measure their Flywheel RPM sensor voltage at idle and confirm if sine wave or square wave and give p-p amplitude (or amplitude VAC reading with a multimeter)?
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  8. eulk328

    eulk328 F1 Rookie

    Feb 18, 2005
    2,800
    Full Name:
    F683
    It seems you have been exceedingly thorough in your troubleshooting so far. Not sure any of us can help from a distance (unless someone can provide a known good waveform!). I would have thought the expected waveforms would be shown in one of the technical manuals but something tells me you already own all the manuals available :) so it must not be in there.

    Any chance of a loose/damaged/missing tooth/teeth where the sensor picks up the impulses?

     
  9. carlrose

    carlrose Formula Junior

    Nov 25, 2003
    327
    Hi Steve,

    Similar symptom in my 328, FoH (who obviously knows of what they speak) mentioned this was normal so I stopped worrying. Car runs fine, just annoying "puffs" at exhaust at idle. Here's my readings (idle 1000 RPM @ Microplex multiconnector):

    TDC sensor; AC voltage 0.590v (spec >0.2v)
    RPM sensor: AC 1.684v (spec >2.0v)

    I posted these # a few years back and someone else had found similar values. Apologies I don't have a scope. Is your advance timing steady at idle? The factory provides a clearance spec for the TDC and RPM sensors, but they're not "adjustable".

    I have an article with photos on running the Microplex diagnostics (as you've already done) with photos for the 328. If it would be useful, shoot me an email at [email protected]. Let me know if taking any other readings would be helpful. You're a great resource to others, shall return the favor if I can.

    Best,

    Carl
     

Share This Page