Rolex sky dweller or deep sea

I have a blue face stainless steel Skydweller - for sure it is more of a dressy watch with the fluted bezel and Jubilee bracelet. I generally wear it if I'm going out to dinner etc. So if you're not wanting a dressy style watch I'd go for the Deep Sea. I have a friend that has the Deep Sea - it's a big chunky watch. If you're leaning in that direction, I'd suggest trying one on to see how you like it. I've tried it on, and it's too big and heavy for my wrist. He has a bigger wrist so I think it works for him. The oyster bracelet is also less dressy. Love the James Cameron version too.

 

You might consider a GMT Master II.

Image Unavailable, Please Login

 

Robb, have you tried on a Rolex GMT? The 40mm thing is a bit misleading. That's the diameter of the case but the lug to lug length is the most important measurement. I'd make the argument that a modern 40mm Rolex watch wears closer to 42-43mm models from other brands.

Ultimately, if you want a Rolex with a GMT function you're limited to the GMT-Master II and Sky-Dweller. If you're OK with a 2 time zone watch then the Explorer II is an option.

 

I’m biased, but go Deep Sea …. Bought this one from JAM1

https://www.ferrarichat.com/forum/threads/rolex-deepsea-d-blue-james-cameron.618663/

MDS

 

Take a look at the Yatch-Master II if you want a big Rolex.

 

I have both a YM2 and Sea Dweller. Yes YM2 is one trick pony but it looks so good. Sea Dweller is a nice in between size that is not as big and chunky as Deep Sea. It’s my daily now.

 

Yup, not a fan of the YM II either. That's the problem with Rolex, all models with the exception of the DD are just a variation of the same watch which makes the Sky-Dweller unique in the line up. If it has to be a Rolex, the Sky-Dweller is the better choice, you get more watch for your money. Now if your first/only concern is value retention then I'd look at other brands and pass on the SD & DS, if not, old adage...buy what you like.

 

I have a regular Submariner and a James Cameron Deep Sea... ( as well as polar explorer, daytona etc... ) I like the Deep Sea best outside the Daytona. Its big and chunky, and the blue to black fade is really eye catching..... My wife wears my sub most of the time... the Deep sea looks better on me.

 

FIFY


Mike

 

Blue dial Dweller! My son just got one and it’s amazing.

 

Sea-Dweller for me is the perfect Rolex. Has that Submariner style but not the small 40mm look feel. I use to have a lot of Rolex around 12 of them....sold them all when prices in 2021-2022 went insane and only kept 1...my Sea-Dweller.

Glad I sold too as prices for used can fallen and now with all the report coming out of Chinese parts manufacturing for Rolex and other high end Lux brands super glad I got out of watched and made money when it was good. I kept my SeaDweller and my AP ROO Elephant but might sell the AP one day in the near future as I never wear it.

 

All the best with "the List". I've bought many Rolex from a local Tampa AD ( Mayors and another store that is no longer around) back in the day and have been on this so called BS list for ever and a day. Then a couple local guys I know who did not have any real past buying with Mayors can waltz into Mayors and pick up Rolex's that they immediately flip. These AD's all over the world pretty much sell to flippers all the time who will buy multiple new Rolex from the AD and the AD keeps these Rolex in back just for the flipper to come in and take the inventory.

 

Well I have both a James Cameron Deep Sea and a rose gold sky dweller with the black band. The deep sea (non James Cameron) is more common. I have seen three in the last week. They are much bigger than almost anything. I like the weight and size, but mostly wear it riding a motorcycle or when doing manual labor. It seems indestructible. The Sky Dweller is wonderful and although I have many watches, I seem to lean toward it very often. It is a great watch for multiple time zones as already mentioned. I have it on presently in flight to Asia.

 

I am a big fan of the Sky Dweller in Everose Gold on an Oysterflex band.

https://www.rolex.com/en-us/watches/sky-dweller/m336235-0003#/m336235-0003/dial

 

I had a Deep Sea for many years but sold it in 2021 when price went nuts. I have a Sea-Dweller now and wear it much more. I am a big guys too 6'5" 225lbs so the Deep Sea fit well but I like the Sea Dweller much much better for how it fits and looks and feels. I love the Sky Dweller as well and have tried many on but never bought one as I am not into building up a watch collection again. My AP ROO and Sea Dweller are perfect and enough.

 

All high polished surfaces scratch much easier than satin/brushed surfaces. Since the two tone has high polished center links, it'll be a magnet for scuffs/scratches. The steel version has an all satin/brushed bracelet so it'll be much better in that regard.

I am getting a 2024 126600 in this week or next as an fyi.

 

From my experience in the watch world, the two tone models, depreciate while the SS models retain / appreciate over time. the gold looks nice, but when they start to scratch it look bad.... white gold looks really good, but it scratches easier as well... My patek is scratch like crazy since I wear it a lot..... a major reason I like SS watches.

 

I love the deep sea ... or sea dweller. I have the James Cameron one, and while its heavy, I love the look and feel. once you wear it, its not as heavy or noticeable as you may think. Unless you want a brand new from the AD watch.... I have a guy in Philly that can source like new / NOS Rolex... at very competitive prices. LMK if you like his contact.