550 Differential Broken – NIGHTMARE, help!!! | FerrariChat

550 Differential Broken – NIGHTMARE, help!!!

Discussion in 'Technical Q&A' started by EVartanian, Aug 8, 2006.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. EVartanian

    EVartanian Formula 3

    Mar 19, 2002
    1,180
    Sunny SoCal
    Full Name:
    Eric
    #1 EVartanian, Aug 8, 2006
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    I really would appreciate any input you guys might have regarding the following problem. The nightmare part is the potential cost. We’re doing all the work at our own shop. The problem occurred after a mild freeway drive. After exiting and coasting down the off ramp, the car was put into neutral. As the light turned, first gear was engaged and as the car moved into traffic, it seemed like the car suddenly lost the clutch and the car wouldn’t respond to throttle accompanied by light metallic rotating noises from underneath. Clutch still had positive pressure though.

    The car: USA 2000 550 w/ almost 19,000mi.

    The symptoms:

    Car on the ground: Tested in 1st, 2nd, and 3rd gears, when engaging the clutch, the car would gently rock forward as if trying to move while making a metallic slipping type noise coming from a rotating part, seeming like clutch won’t engage.

    Car on the lift: Would engage the gear and wheels would rotate, but still make a similar noise congruent with rotation of wheels.

    The Diagnosis:

    At first, we hopefully suspected a clutch issue. After taking the drivetrain apart and getting to the clutch, everything looked generally in good shape—clutch fine, nothing shattered or broken, no leaks. While we were there, we decided to fit a complete new clutch assembly with new t/o bearing, seals, etc. for maintenance and slightly hoping it might fix something we couldn’t see or were missing. Put in new fluids, bolt everything back together. End result, same symptoms still there!

    Since the gearbox seemed perfect, we suspected something wrong with the differential and axles. Opened up the back of the diff. and spun some wheels and it was clear that something had broken inside the differential. Found some metal pieces in there as well.

    In the diagrams below, I’ve circled where the problem so far seems to be coming from.

    The Solutions:

    The dealer no longer sells the differential or pieces of the differential separately from the gearbox, like assembly #5 in the diagram. You must now purchase the complete gearbox/differential assembly. Maybe the entire unit has been upgraded? This would be the easiest bolt-on solution, but the price is outrageous.

    We’ve sourced another complete gearbox/diff assembly from a euro ’98 car with 30,000km (~18,600mi). for a little less than half the price of new. This seems a decent option, but comes the risk of a used part, plus we kinda like our gearbox, and the car is older and euro. Anyone know of any upgrades to the gearbox/diff from '98 to '00 or of any differences with euro?

    We’re also considering rebuilding the diff. if we can source the parts. A bit trickier.

    We’re still assessing our options. No rush. I welcome all of your input or technical feedback on the various options or finding a solution. Does anyone have any suggestions for other resources we might try.

    What caused this to happen, why, and how are also some perplexing concerns, hopefully unrelated to any other components, which we hope to figure out. First time I've seen/heard of this problem.

    Staying optimistic...

    Eric
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  2. Rifledriver

    Rifledriver Three Time F1 World Champ

    Apr 29, 2004
    37,288
    Cowboy Capitol of the World
    Full Name:
    Brian Crall
    Sorry to hear that the weak diff story that started with the Daytona is still with us. Also sorry it happened to you.

    First get it appart enough to be certain what you are dealing with and make a parts list. Next, FNA has a habit of requiring you to buy complete components when in the rest of the world Ferrari will sell al la cart. Try Ricambi America or Ferrari UK and see if parts are available that way from across the water.


    BTW as with most driveline failures, what you were doing when it quit was not what broke it. It was a prior event or lifetime of events that killed it.
     
  3. geekstreet

    geekstreet Karting

    Feb 7, 2005
    220
    Sydney
    Full Name:
    Cam
    From the diagram, it's a German ZF LSD. Hopefully the spider assembly (if that's what has gone) is available from the manufacturer, as there's a good chance it's a unit common with other large-capacity vehicles (big BMWs, etc?).
     
  4. No Doubt

    No Doubt Seven Time F1 World Champ

    May 21, 2005
    72,740
    Vegas+Alabama
    Full Name:
    Mr. Sideways
    I'm sure it's unrelated, but what brand of gearbox oil were you using?
     
  5. Darkhorse575

    Darkhorse575 Formula Junior

    Mar 20, 2005
    634
    Pasadena, CA
    Full Name:
    DJ
    Probably not. My 740iL had a recall as the transmission was known to fail if the wrong gear oil is used.
     
  6. EVartanian

    EVartanian Formula 3

    Mar 19, 2002
    1,180
    Sunny SoCal
    Full Name:
    Eric
    Thanks Brian, shot em a couple emails, some promising feedback from both.

    We were using the factory recommended Shell oil.

    I'll keep you all updated.
     
  7. osuav8r

    osuav8r Karting

    Feb 16, 2005
    142
    Houston, TX
    Full Name:
    Alan
    My uncle had an old International tractor that broke an axle. He couldn't get the part because it was obsolete so he had one made. If you could find a good machine/fabrication shop they should be able to make something that would work. I guess it would depend on what actually broke, I''m not really clear on what you actually broke. I know for a fact that companies like Strange Engineering will make custom length/spline count axles for hot rods so they might be worth a shot. As I recall, they only charged like $350 for a custom made set of axles for a mustang with whatever spline count you wanted. Might be worth some research, hope that helps.
     
  8. ferrarilou

    ferrarilou Formula Junior

    Apr 13, 2004
    513
    US
    Full Name:
    Lou Menditto
    Do you perchance have the ZF numbers stamped on the side of the diff housing? Not sure if it will be fruitful, but you could try to search for a diff for an alternate car with the name numbers. This presumes that such a beast exists :)


    Lou
     
  9. ernie

    ernie Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa Owner

    Nov 19, 2001
    22,620
    The Brickyard
    Full Name:
    The Bad Guy
    Hey Eric,

    Sorry to hear about your "dif"ficulties ;). Having just finished going through gear box troubles I feel your pain. While I had my gear box apart I rebuilt the dif too. Nothing was busted, I just atlernated the cross plates and abrasive disc, the same way they are in your car. You can read about it here, with pics even :D http://ferrarichat.com/forum/showthread.php?t=102751

    Going by the diagram you posted your dif looks almost exactly the same as the dif in my 348. So it is pretty simple to take apart.

    From what you are describing I'm gonna have to guess that the cross bracket/s, that hold the spider gears in place, is busted and you could also have destoryed the spider gear/s, maybe even the sun gear. You won't know what kind of carnage went on inside till you take it apart. I'm hoping it is just the cross bracket that is busted. The reason I think it is the cross bracket is because you are hearing noise. The spider gears are mounted on the ends of the bracket, and if the bracket is broken it won't hold the gears properly inside the cups and will alow the spider gears to disengage from the sun gear, that is the one that looks like a pinion gear that the axle flanges get bolted to. Anyway, if the spider gears disengage from the sun gear, they won't be able to apply the proper preasure against the cups, to get them to spread so that the cross plates and discs lock. Which is why the car wouldn't move even though it was in gear. It is also why you were hearing the noise.

    So the only thing for you to do it tear appart the diff to see what kind of nightmare you are dealing with. Hopefully you will only have to replace the cross brackets and maybe a spider gear.

    You can try calling ZF's automotive and see if they can get you what you need (847) 478-6868 or try the website http://www.zf-group.com/am/pc/pt/ampcpt05.phtml It would be best if you had the numbers ready for them when you call. Ferrari DOES NOT make any of the parts for the gear box, they are made by Zahnradfabrik so don't even bother with dealing with FNA. ZF makes the tranny so don't give up trying to get the parts you need. Like I said if you have the part number handy I'll bet they can get you what you need. If not, then Dan is your man. http://www.ricambiamerica.com/

    Hope I was of some help.
     
  10. EVartanian

    EVartanian Formula 3

    Mar 19, 2002
    1,180
    Sunny SoCal
    Full Name:
    Eric
    Thanks for the continuing support. Sorry I haven't been able to update with some pictures, I'll try to get some up soon. Haven't taken it completely to pieces yet till we had some real options to think about. We'll probably get to that this week. Both Ricambi and Ferrari UK have been very helpful in trying to find a solution. FOC actually was able to locate assembly #5 from the diagram in Maranello, and it looks like we'll be having that shipped over. It seems the original part has been replaced with a different p/n, so maybe/hopefully Ferrari discovered a weak link and updated the part. Harmony Autosport (sponsor) also suggested that they'd likely be able to reproduce a stronger part, but I think we might just replace the whole diff, we'll see.

    I'd browsed through the ZF site for some leads, but never tried directly calling them. It'd be interesting to know what they'd have to say about it all, so I'll also try that number and fill you in on the results. Ernie, I followed your diff' iculties from the beginning...great thread!
     
  11. ernie

    ernie Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa Owner

    Nov 19, 2001
    22,620
    The Brickyard
    Full Name:
    The Bad Guy
    Yeah, I'm curious to know what they have to say about it too. Please do keep us posted on it.
     
  12. ernie

    ernie Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa Owner

    Nov 19, 2001
    22,620
    The Brickyard
    Full Name:
    The Bad Guy
    Bump.

    Any updates on the status of the diff?
     
  13. Newman

    Newman F1 World Champ
    Consultant Owner Professional Ferrari Technician

    Dec 26, 2001
    14,512
    Canada
    Full Name:
    Newman
    Modena engineering in austrailia makes aftermarket carriers for boxers and many other race proven parts. You can try them as well.
     
  14. ASU SAE

    ASU SAE Karting

    Aug 8, 2004
    59
    CA
    Full Name:
    T
    If you wanted to know the technical specifics of the diff, it is a Salisbury type differential. As to how it works, the angular gears mounted on the shafts (circled in the pic above) rotate with the diff in operation. Those four gears are the connection between the two half shafts but will rotate when the two half shafts are at different angular velocities (allowing for the differetiation... essentially an open diff).

    Where this diff locks and provides its limited slip capabilities are in the clutchpacks to either side of the gears. The shafts, onto which the angular bevel gears are mounted to, stick out and ride on ramps that will put pressure on the clutch packs, locking each side up (independant of each other). The ramps may be profiled to have different locking characteristics for thrust coming from the engine and thrust in the opposite direction coming from the brakes.

    The Salisbury type of differential is a pretty good style of diff (Hewland uses this style with their Powerflow diff). It's probably one of the best for a purely mechnical fricition diff as it allows for different amounts of lock from the engine and the brakes. It's much better than a Torsen style or Quaife ATB type diff that rely on on friction from pressre angles between the helical and worm gears in them (essentially an open diff with some torque biasing) and bias torque the same for both the engine and the brakes. It still isn't as good as some viscous-coupling locking diffs. Many top-end motorsports differential manufacturers (X-Trac, Ricardo, etc.) prefer using a combination viscous-coupling and clutchplate combination for maximum tuneability. That's probably the best for passively acting differentials... once you get into active differentials like the F430 has it's another story completely and much closer to an ideal situation.

    If I lost you on some of this stuff, check out http://auto.howstuffworks.com/differential.htm. It has some good animations that explain a bit. The clutch type diff they have has a spring in it that provides some preload, but isn't the source of the torque biasing (a little confusing how they have it worded).

    Tim
     

Share This Page