Challenge Stradale: A Challenge Indeed.... | FerrariChat

Challenge Stradale: A Challenge Indeed....

Discussion in 'United Kingdom' started by Gibbsa, Jul 19, 2005.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. Gibbsa

    Gibbsa Karting

    Jul 20, 2004
    68
    Here and there
    Full Name:
    Gibbsa
    #1 Gibbsa, Jul 19, 2005
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    I took delivery of my Stradale in Switzerland last September and was, as you can imagine, delighted beyond belief. Having previously owned a 355, I was used to the ways of the 'F' car and therefore expected the occasional teething problem. I wasn't surprised then, when an exhaust rattle, at a little over 4k kms, required a new end section - keeping it off the road for 3weeks.

    At the end of May, another 'rattle', this time from the engine, sounded a little more sinister. While the car continued to function- move - it sounded like something was moving faster, but in time with the revs of the engine, than the pistons themselves. More accurately, it sounded as if a number of ball bearings were being swirled around in an empty tin can – in time with the engine. The car, now in the UK, was duly handed to Maranello Motors (under warranty) and after examination and replacement of the cams, belts etc etc, the car was nailed back together – no changed, same problem.

    3weeks ago and the word from the factory came – 1 new engine required. This is being fitted as we speak (it arrived today) – and the car has been off the road for a further 9weeks. Now before the questions, I should point out that I am not a heavy driver – I enjoy, yes, but I don’t thrash. I take care and, being as this is a life dream that I will not likely repeat (I am struggling to convince my bank manager that it’s not a car, more a life support system), I try and do all the things that one should driving such a fine car (low revs when cold etc etc).

    So, the questions then, and I only have 2.

    Is there anything I can do, other than accept the fact that I must simply drive, wait for it to break, put up with the time to source parts and fit? I had to beg a courtesy car – which to be fair, Maranello have now provided foc, but why is dealing with Ferrari such a chore.

    I’ve paid over £130k for a car that has been off the road nearly 3months of its 10month life? Chap in Germany is suing for a car that won’t do 300kmh, mine won’t do 0.3kmh most of the time….

    And finally, the car (remarkably), is due for its 1st service. So, forgetting that it been off the road for so long (while depreciating horribly) what would I expect to pay for a first service that shouldn’t include oil, plugs, filters, etc etc – remember, it’s a new engine . I’ve not finished discussing with those nice people at Maranello, but it seems the factory is screwing them, so they have to screw me! Hmmm, would be interested in what else needs doing and what would be fair.

    That said… I love it – it is wonderful! I just wished those that look after them ‘officially’ had as much passion and love for them and not just the £ as those that look after them ‘unofficially’ – and of course those that own and pay for them.

    Thanks for your comments.
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  2. spcheekuk

    spcheekuk Karting

    Nov 27, 2003
    76
    Kent
    Full Name:
    Stephen
    You have my sympathy. I have an identical car, no problems so far (1 year, 2600 miles), except a minor rattle from the battery cover corrected under warranty by Graypaul.
     
  3. 360

    360 Karting

    Feb 27, 2004
    127
    Orpington Kent
    Full Name:
    Chris M
    My sympathy for your trouble.
    This is similar to my experience with Maranello's and Ferrari and why now i drive a Lamborghini, still had a few teething problems but they are on it straight away, pick up, courtesy car, up date phone calls the full monty.
    Ferrari was a life time dream and I may one day try again but the men at Maranello's were my nightmare.
    If you have any more problems ask for Mario at Greypaul, he's a great guy and is passionate about Ferrari, a quality missing in much of the network
    Good luck and remember "it takes less muscles to smile than to frown"
    so save energy and smile
     
  4. steve f

    steve f F1 World Champ

    Mar 15, 2004
    12,119
    12cylinder town
    Full Name:
    steve
    take it to the motoring press i am sure they will not like that at ferrari and may do something to sort you out
     
  5. F328GTS

    F328GTS Formula 3

    Apr 27, 2004
    1,628
    Cambridgeshire, UK
    Full Name:
    Nigel R
    Sounds like the car was not "fit for purpose". You may be entitled to a refund, or new car. Certainly some compensation should be due, surely?
     
  6. 5to1

    5to1 Formula Junior

    Mar 15, 2004
    523
    If it was defective on purchase, then I believe you can ask for a refund. Not how it would work with a purchase from switzerland though.

    If you can't show it was defective from day one, I believe you have to give them reasonable opportunity to fix the problems. Is 3 months down out of 10 months reasonable? Difficult to say. For how many of those 3 months did u have a courtesy car? And was it of a similar nature to the CS?
     
  7. murph7355

    murph7355 Formula 3

    Nov 30, 2002
    1,691
    SE England Yorkie
    Full Name:
    Andy
    I'm afraid its for these reasons I won't go near the main dealer network again, and can't see me ever buying a new Ferrari.

    It's not even that you have to experience faults on a car like this that yaanks my chain. My heart rules my head in these matters and I can usually live with it (depsite my head knowing it's completely unacceptable). I'll forgive a pretty face with a big mouth anything :)

    It's the fact that you have hassle after hassle with the firm when problems do arise. You shouldn't have to ask for loan cars (commensurate to the one that is off the road). Nor should you have to ask for compensation.

    If they 'fessed up, let you borrow a 430 while it was off the road (or a Maser, 612 etc. Or even a different one each week) and then said

    "we're really sorry Paolo had too much chianti on Friday lunchtime and dropped his nipple ring in no.3 cylinder when you're engine was being glued together, here are a couple of vouchers for your next two services on us and please accept this invite to the factory where you'll be able to have a go round the test track as well as have a look round the factory and stay at the hotel opposite on us", the world would seem a much nicer place and the heart would take over from Mr Head once more.

    Sadly, you may as well have bought a Ford or a Nissan.

    At least they're covering it under warranty. Just wait a few years when they won't even stand by that...
     
  8. udalmia

    udalmia Guest

    you have my sympathy :(
     
  9. 400SPYDER

    400SPYDER F1 Rookie

    Jul 7, 2004
    3,473
    Kent, England
    Full Name:
    kevan
    Andrew saw the begining of your story in the Euro thread - whilst all the Fchat sympathy in the world isn't going to help - that appears to be all we can offer.

    Has Fchat ever considered hiring an 'expert' that could be on retainer to advise us all on such matters ? I have presumed that FOC wouldn't offer somethimg similar due to their close affiliation with the factory.

    Do you think it will be ready in time for Scotland - or will you bring the loaner anyway ? Hope to see you there.
     
  10. ferrari355gtb

    ferrari355gtb Formula 3

    Nov 3, 2003
    1,600
    UK
    Full Name:
    R
  11. Gibbsa

    Gibbsa Karting

    Jul 20, 2004
    68
    Here and there
    Full Name:
    Gibbsa
    ..are being expressed which worry me slightly, but unfortunatley don't surprise. I think the 'fit for purpose' is not an argument worth going to just yet - maybe engine number 3 if it comes to that, would force that one.

    As for online and offline comments about the 'official' dealer network, well, there is certainly a lot of angst out there - which I will be joining if I am really required to part with £1,000.00 for a 'first' service on a new engined car to retain my warranty - we will see.

    I will defer comments on the rest of the story until the car is back under my backside, where it belongs as the experience here, simply in talking £ is a million miles from an excellent experience with Zenith in CH.

    As for the replacement car - no, not even close to being 'like' - my request for a loaner to get me to the mens finals at wimbledon and treat Nathalie as I really wanted (a very special birthday present) was actually laughed at!!! I now have an X-type that I am actually feeling guilty about moaning about - which I know I shouldn't...I spent +£130k for heavens sake!!!!!

    Interesting that Karl Verdi offered me a car straight away for wimbledon. No hassle, no charge, no anything - just 'Andy, how can I help? I have this Fcar you can borrow' ! The loaner in CH when off the road was a Maserati Quattroporte.

    The car, I have been informed, should be ready for Scotland and I am planning a pickup early next week. I am as intrigued as the rest to know which way I will fall - somewhere, deep down though, I am preparing myself for more disappointment when we get to discuss the bill for the service...
     
  12. daz355

    daz355 Formula Junior

    Jan 31, 2004
    743
    MclarenVille
    Full Name:
    Darren P
    Sorry tohear about your bad experience.I would ask for a full refund as the car could be classed as faulty goods.
     
  13. noony

    noony F1 Veteran

    Nov 25, 2003
    5,903
    Seoul
    Full Name:
    Johnathan
    A sorry sight. Is there not a Europe-wide ''lemon law'', where if a car is off the road for a certain amount of time, you are entitled to a replacement car or refund?
     
  14. Gibbsa

    Gibbsa Karting

    Jul 20, 2004
    68
    Here and there
    Full Name:
    Gibbsa
    Thanks Rick, seems I am not alone. I have posted my experience and have received interesting feedback. I am considering a new thread - perhaps when this experience is over (I had another call today - more parts needed, waiting for factory to deliver!!!, this on day it was supposed to be ready).

    My suggestion is to introduce 'experience' league tables of dealers (official and un) and owners experiences of dealing with them. Moderated, based on proven experiences (provide dealer, model, miles/kms, experience and perhaps other details) and give a number of points per experience. We can then start building a picture of those cars that are lemons (or more lemonish than others :D) and dealers, that in our humble opinions, SUCK!

    I for one would have liked to see a 'current position' of said dealer before committing my car. Hmmm...I'm thinking now - and that normally means trouble...
     
  15. murph7355

    murph7355 Formula 3

    Nov 30, 2002
    1,691
    SE England Yorkie
    Full Name:
    Andy
    Posted on PH in reply to yours.

    Problem with moderated league tables is who moderates them? And how do you tell the stories are from genuine experiences? Also, how do you tell that the dealer was given a fair crack at sorting it? We've had episodes on here across the spectrum and such a thing is fraught with hassle.

    Best bet is to do a search on here and take a balance of the views IMO. And if you have a specific dealer you want to use, search for them on here.

    And without wishing to worry you more, I'd double insist that they get a courier to get you parts here now. Otherwise your next call from them will be "they're out of stock of the lower captive 19.5mm fibre washer we need, and the factory has now closed down for summer holidays. We'll get the bits in September." Natch.

    You must start getting very firm with them, and only deal with the dealer principle or Ferrari UK from here on in. You've spent 130k+ in all likelihood, and Ferrari should be sitting up and listening VERY hard.
     
  16. hedge

    hedge Formula 3

    Jun 11, 2003
    2,320
    England
    Full Name:
    Marc
    and in the mean time they need to supply you with an alternative suitable vehicle in case it's not ready for a certain trip!
     
  17. zsnnf

    zsnnf Formula 3

    Sep 11, 2003
    1,877
    If Ferrari is fitting a new engine, I don't see why it would be due for a service. It should recieve the same first free service you get when you buy a new car.
    I'm not sure I understand your depreciating like a rock comment. Used CS's are selling for over list price still over here.

    Rick
     
  18. matkat

    matkat Formula 3

    Mar 18, 2003
    1,840
    Scotland
    Full Name:
    Dave McGuire
    Andy,You have My sympathy also and as for the Dealer network! well We will be able to discuss this next week(hopefully)In Scotland.
    Dave Mc
     
  19. Gibbsa

    Gibbsa Karting

    Jul 20, 2004
    68
    Here and there
    Full Name:
    Gibbsa
    I asked the same question on the service - new engine, I hardly need plugs, oil, filters etc etc, let alone the time. The response was brakes (checks), fluids, tracking, alignment, time and a lot of 'other' items that sounded non-too reasonable if you ask me. I am interested in other views because I have yet to conclude the 'right' price on this yet - and bottom line, I STILL don't have the car back. What else can they possibly have to do that justifies £1k?

    On the 'free' service, the car is Swiss, not UK and therefore not included in purchase price (is it really included in UK?). And that's my problem with the resale/depreciation - I have enquired on sale (new house etc etc) and because its lhd, there is no real sensible interest over here and there are so many coming up for resale over there due to 430 etc that it simply isnt worth it (which, deep down I am happy with - at least I can say to my partner I tried, but it is still worrying in case I was really, really in a dark place and HAD to sell it). Difficult I know with an import - I guess its best for me not to look :D
     
  20. Gibbsa

    Gibbsa Karting

    Jul 20, 2004
    68
    Here and there
    Full Name:
    Gibbsa
    ..and in the meantime, they are certainly aware of the NEED to get it back to me for THE trip, yes. Parts are being couriered and I for one am more than aware of the practice of Italy shutting down for August. Car delivery was delayed by 5weeks from promised date - that is drop dead we promise it will be delivered end of June 04 (after 3 other broken promises and constant calls). It arrived in time for Autumn, September 16th.

    The good news - I have been PROMISED (see above) - it WILL be ready Friday!

    The bad news (ooooh, your so gonna laugh...), it won't be back from the paint shop until tomorrow afternoon..yep, paint shop - you got me...paint shop!..Lordy...give me strength...

    It will be ready...it will. Despite my experiences I am a natural born optimist ... I look forward to the 'Keep bar' where I can share with you all on the trip what it has really been like...I hope there is enough scotch!
    :D
    (it will be ready...it will..it will...it will...)
     
  21. D11VE:J

    D11VE:J Formula 3

    Nov 9, 2004
    1,030
    Your position in law is that you have a right of action to 'Rescind the Purchase Agreement' The problem is it is with the Supplier and not Ferrari. That means that you will have to take action against the Swiss Supplier and you have two choices, Take the car and drop it on their door step notifying them that they have 14 days in which to refund your cash, or you can hand them a Swis Legal writ and handle it through the court.

    Here is the downside, on both counts you have paid and they might take 3-4 years to settle offering counter after counter to drag out the matter in hopes you will give up and go away or die. There are no quick fixes for this situation other than to find a matter in the paperwork that shows they broke the law, for example, I had one dealer by the smalls when I produced a service manual, sold with full service history, that had a stamped non-dealer service agents name in the book they had obvioulsy written in on the basis of a receipt in the car - forged service history.

    Knowing Ferrari you will not be so lucky especially as the car was new.

    I have a Lotus in exactly the same condition if not worse, all you can do my friend is lump it unless you have more money than sense. Find yourself a good Ferrari dealer and appeal to them about the repairs in future, the only thing you can do is take a sweetener before you take the cyanide pill, you are stuck with what you have, you don't have to put up with nonsense, if the repair went wrong and you wasted 3 weeks and achieved nothing, make a small claim for the cost of the car off the road for faulty workmanship. Problem is you will eventually run out of service agents.


    Look at this if it makes you feel better;

    Paid £54,000 Lotus Esprit V8 October 2002.

    10,000 miles running around between garages for repairs, not one day of faultless driving in first 18 months, then 12 months off road being completley resprayed twice, threw the car back at the supplier with 14 days notice of rescinding contract, cowboys wreck it, tracking it, it appears, radio nicked, took the car back after 4 months with absolutely no progress, 3,000 miles more on the clock, total of 16,000 miles driving in first 2½ years, car now worth £25,000.

    It can stay in the shed, it has cost me hundreds of wasted hours and £15,000 in costs and the car is worth less than half what I paid for it. It has near driven me bonkers.

    Don't feel bad, just deal with your car and get what you can as the law provides for the horsetrader not the buyer. If you let this unfortunate interlude upset you then you lose again. Your sanity is worth more.

    It will all come good, try to keep your cool, love and it and sing to it, and it will sort itself out. Best of Luck

    D11VE:J
     
  22. F328GTS

    F328GTS Formula 3

    Apr 27, 2004
    1,628
    Cambridgeshire, UK
    Full Name:
    Nigel R
    WTF is it doing in there? :confused: Have you asked them why?
     
  23. 5to1

    5to1 Formula Junior

    Mar 15, 2004
    523
    Not over here.

    Also

    depreciation = price paid - value now

    and price paid doesn't always equal list price.
     
  24. 360CS

    360CS F1 Rookie

    Nov 1, 2003
    2,641
    Kent
    Full Name:
    Joe J
    Stop dealing with all the inbetweens on this matter go straight to Ferrari in Italy and lodge you complaint with them..

    Write out the whole issue and your disapointment.......Im sure something will be done...these guys are curruntly replacing my Carbonfibre which was reported faulty some time ago .

    I took the bull by the horns after getting nowhere with the main Dealership ...It take time but It does work. If I was you I dont think id of been as patient...and would of issued some legal doc umentation for compensation.....

    I assume you purchased the car new???
     
  25. CUE99T

    CUE99T Formula Junior

    Feb 28, 2004
    838
    Scotland
    Full Name:
    Paul
    Andrew, I know exactly how you feel and I had to plead with Maranello to pick my car up as it was soaking wet inside all over and it was going on for for weeks and all I can say is speak to the very top about it, I eventually was offered a Maserati car for use while they stripped my car down for the third time but I refused and just sold it as thats why I drive German engineering now, as I just couldn't stand the pain any longer but wish for another everyday......it's the love of the marque not the people who sell them or service them that we buy them.

    I like you had been a 355 owner but to be honest it makes no difference you pay to put up and shut up!!

    P
    CUE99T
     

Share This Page