F355 Newest Alternator situation! - Ideas? | FerrariChat

F355 Newest Alternator situation! - Ideas?

Discussion in 'Technical Q&A' started by AZLambo, Aug 12, 2006.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. AZLambo

    AZLambo Formula Junior

    Nov 4, 2003
    511
    Phoenix, AZ
    Full Name:
    Jeff
    Well,

    For those of you following my alternator saga, I decided that my "sensing" wire must have a short or open / intermittant connection somewhere. My auto electric guy decided to put in a new voltage regulator that had a "dead" connection for the sensing wire connection. So basically, I'm guessing it senses the voltage it needs to put out on itself (battery output wire, is that correct?) Anyway, still had the IG and L connections, so the battery light on the dash still comes on when Ignition key is turned on initially. Put in the alternator (pain in the ass.....especially after 3 times). Started up car......14.4 volts.......good..........went for a drive.........settled in at about 13.4 volts.......good........I'm thinking all is fixed! Woo Hoo!...........but NOOOOOOOOOO...........all of a sudden, after the usual 7 to 8 mile drive.....I get a spike of 16.4 volts, the two "check engine" lights come on, the battery light comes on and is bright as hell...........I slow down, get off the freeway, then the voltage briefly went back to around 13.4........all warning lights go out, then another spike at 16.4..all warning lights back on, then, I'm guessing, I blew the voltage regulator, because the voltage is now at 12.05 and the battery light is glowing dimly........It stayed that way all the way home.

    Thoughts?
     
  2. No Doubt

    No Doubt Seven Time F1 World Champ

    May 21, 2005
    72,740
    Vegas+Alabama
    Full Name:
    Mr. Sideways
    A "dead" connection for your sensing wire is what is killing your voltage regulator...no voltage there causes your alternator to spike to max output, frying the v-reg.

    What Wolftalk and others were saying on one of your earlier threads was to connect that sensing wire to the battery output wire (you've always got voltage there) to see if that would bypass your problem.
     
  3. Jeff Pintler

    Jeff Pintler Formula Junior

    Jul 20, 2005
    537
    Richland
    Full Name:
    Jeff Pintler
    Wow, this thread has gone on a long time! As I can recall, you've replaced the large cable to the starter and added several grounds and jumped the battery disconnect switch. By connecting the sense wire to various points and running the wire back into the passenger compartment, you've been able to bypass the rest of the harness. Is that correct? Have you measured directly off the alternator? Does the battery light on the instrument cluster provide a bootstrap current for charging? You would check that by reading the alternator output voltage after disconnecting the small gauge wire that connects to the battery warning light. I ran across something today on a Mercedes list:

    "One problem in putting a warning light here in the circuit is that an automotive alternator, unlike the old DC generators, uses steel in the field pole pieces (the rotor on an alternator) that don't hold residual magnetism, so a "tickler" current is needed to start the generating process when starting the car. Also, if the field circuit opens up, output drops to zero. The GM circuit uses a fairly large shunt resistor across the warning light bulb to assure tickler current if the bulb fails."

    So what would happen if the wire to the instrument cluster (battery light) were to short to ground or short to full battery voltage. It might explain the very bright indication and abunch of other stuff lighting . Would the output from the alternator stop, ie drop from 14 to 12.4? Incidently, sometimes the alternator does output 16 volts to charge the battery. So what I would try is checking alt output voltage without the without the battery warning light. Let us know what happens next.

    And you've also replaced the battery in case there is an intermittant open. If all else fails, you could bypass the harness and run a positive cable from the alt all the way to the battery and then use it to verify the ground connection to the battery.

    I spent a day and a half tracing a problem in a fuel injection system on a 911 and it turned out that the volt meter had too low of input impedance and it was affecting the oxygen sensor output voltage. After getting a 10 megaohm dvm, everything was fine. That which doesn't kill us makes us stronger. Good luck!

    Jeff Pintler
    89 348(major almost done), 86 TR (won 1st in a car show today)
     
  4. gdbsti

    gdbsti Formula Junior

    Oct 10, 2004
    283
    Nor Cal
    Full Name:
    Bruce
    What was the results of your voltage tests while running the car with the fault present?
     
  5. AZLambo

    AZLambo Formula Junior

    Nov 4, 2003
    511
    Phoenix, AZ
    Full Name:
    Jeff
    Here's what I've done so far, and the results: (from start to finish)
    (All voltage figures were read from a digital voltmeter plugged into the
    cigarette lighter)

    Originally:

    1. After about 8 months on a new alternator, while driving, the battery light came on, alternator was not charging. Voltage readings were just over 12 with battery charged up and would drop slowly when driving. Battery light would stay on. Bought new battery (just because the existing one was 3 years old) (Interstate MT- 34R) Drove car to Ferrari dealer early in the morning, and made it without car stopping. Voltage was just below 12 when I got there. Ferrari dealer installed a new alternator. I picked up car and started driving home. Voltage was 13.5. After 7 or 8 miles, the voltage started to drop, going down to just over 12, battery light came on. Alternator was not charging again. Took car back to Ferrari dealer.

    2. Dealer had the car for a week or two. Did some electrical tests. Could not find anything wrong except for the alternator that they had put in had gone bad. Replaced with another alternator. I picked up the car. Started driving home. Same thing happened about 8 miles down the road. It was too
    late to go back to the dealer, so I continued home, but every once-in-a-while, the alternator would start charging again, and then go "dead" again.

    3. After hearing various suggestions for you good Ferrari folks, I concentrated on finding "bad grounds" and "corroded positive" connections.
    I bypassed the kill switch, cleaned and tightened all ground cables and connections, including the ground strap to the alternator case. Replaced the positive cables from the alternator and the starter to the junction block in the engine compartment. Had an alternator rebuild by a recommended auto electric guy, and installed it. Took car for a drive. Voltage settled in nicely at about 13.5, then, after about 8 miles, the voltage started creeping UP.
    Once it hit 14, the battery light started flickering. Voltage kept going UP, and battery light went to solid ON. Voltage hit over 16. Pulled off road.
    Voltage started back down, and settled in at 13.5. Drove another 8 miles, and voltage started creeping UP again. Same thing happened as above. Every time I would slow down and come to a stop, the voltage would come back down to 13.5, and stay there for about another 8 miles. HAVE YOU NOTICED THIS "8-MILE" THING! WHAT COULD GET "TRIGGERED" EVERY 8 MILES?...AND THEN CLEAR ITSELF, AND THEN HAPPEN AGAIN 8 MILES LATER?

    4. Anyway, I ran a ground wire straight from the negative cable on the battery to the alternator case. The alternator IS NOW GROUNDED FOR SURE!!! I got the same "8-mile" creeping UP voltage. Went to the auto electric guy, he thought to replace the voltage regulator with one that had
    a "dead terminal" for the "sense" wire. He and I thought that somehow the sense wire was "opening" or something that would trigger the voltage overcharge. NOW I AM ASSUMING THAT SUCH A VOLTAGE REGULATOR WOULD EITHER PUT OUT A CONSTANT 13.5 (OR THEREABOUTS) VOLTAGE, OR WOULD HAVE AN "INTERNAL SENSING TO THE OUTPUT TERMINAL", SO THAT IN ESSENCE, WOULD "SENSE" WHATEVER THE ALTERNATOR WAS PUTTING OUT AS THE SYSTEM VOLTAGE. IS THIS CORRECT? I DON'T THINK THAT SUCH A VOLTAGE REGULATOR WOULD JUST HAVE AN "OPEN" SENSE TERMINAL, WHICH WOULD "FRY" THE ALTERATOR. Anyway, after the 8 mile drive, I got the voltage "spike", not the "creeping up" voltage, but a straight shift from 13.5 to 16.4, like RIGHT NOW! This is when the "check engine" lights came on and the battery light came on bright. Then, the spike left breifly, then it "hit" again, and then left again, but this time the voltage went down to 12.04 volts and I knew that the voltage regulator was "toast".

    Just for the record, the voltage from the cigarette lighter corresponds exactly to the voltage at the battery.........I have checked.

    Well, that is the story.

    What now?
     
  6. Whisky

    Whisky Three Time F1 World Champ
    Silver Subscribed

    Jan 27, 2006
    32,254
    In the flight path to Offutt
    Full Name:
    The original Fernando
    Dumb idea, but I'm famous for them:

    Could it be 8 miles, or could it be X minutes ?
    (however many minutes it takes you to go 'about' 8 miles)
     
  7. AZLambo

    AZLambo Formula Junior

    Nov 4, 2003
    511
    Phoenix, AZ
    Full Name:
    Jeff
    good point. I am trying to think of what component or problem could be "triggered" in every 8 miles or 8 minutes. A shorted or open wire, once affected by the heat of the engine, etc., I could see going "bad" after the 8 minutes or 8 miles, but wouldn't it continue to be "bad" from then on? Why, when I slow down, whatever the problem is seems to "reset itself" and then go bad again in 8 miles or 8 minutes. I have a feeling that it is an "8 minutes of driving" thing. What could it be?
     
  8. gdbsti

    gdbsti Formula Junior

    Oct 10, 2004
    283
    Nor Cal
    Full Name:
    Bruce
    The fault may be a the alt/reg, a battery going open circuit, or more likely a wiring connector issue/hi resistance problem somewere...

    The process to fault find your problem in a methodical manner has already been posted. I apologize if what I wrote hasn't been understood.

    With it being a continuous fault it is defintly traceable, given a bit of work and some patience.

    Good luck.
     
  9. AZLambo

    AZLambo Formula Junior

    Nov 4, 2003
    511
    Phoenix, AZ
    Full Name:
    Jeff
    gdbsti,

    I must not have understood your systematic "tests" to find the problem.
    Could you list them, in order of probabilities, and exactly how to accomplish each task? Remember, I am not that electronically literite.

    Thanks,
    AZFerrari
     
  10. ROLOcr

    ROLOcr Formula Junior

    Oct 25, 2005
    619
    Costa Rica
    Full Name:
    ROLO
    one question, is the RPM gauge connected to the alternator like on classic range rovers? if so, once i had a friend with frecuent alternator problems and after checking EVERYTHING it turn out to be a problem with the dash itself
    not likely and a long shot BUT you never know, good luck
     
  11. ernie

    ernie Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa Owner

    Nov 19, 2001
    22,620
    The Brickyard
    Full Name:
    The Bad Guy
    Just a suggestion but, have you tried bypassing the starter? I don't know if it has anything to do with your alternator, but maybe something to do with the connection there. There reason I'm TOTALLY GUESSING this is because on the early 348s there is a bullet style connector running from the battery to the starter. If the connector somehow were to get loose, or come undone, the car would run on the battery, and not the alternator, until the battery went dead. Ask me how I know. So maybe the path from your alternator to your battery follows the same path as on my 348, Alternator -> starter-> battery? To me it is a dumb way to route power to the battery. Maybe, just maybe it has something to do with the soleniod in the starter that is giving you all the grief, or something having to do with the path the power is following, rather than the alternator itself? It could be back feeding the power or something? Again, totally guessing here?
     
  12. AZLambo

    AZLambo Formula Junior

    Nov 4, 2003
    511
    Phoenix, AZ
    Full Name:
    Jeff
    Both the starter and the alternator positive leads go to a junction block in the engine compartment, where they meet up with the positive battery cable. They are separate leads. Maybe Ferrari learned something!
     
  13. Jeff Pintler

    Jeff Pintler Formula Junior

    Jul 20, 2005
    537
    Richland
    Full Name:
    Jeff Pintler
    Remember that the cig lighter is probably connected to the fuse panel which connects to the battery through a large gauge wire directly through a fuse. The reason I was suggesting running a fused line directly to the alternator terminal is so you will bypass all of the cabling that ties back to the battery and you could find out exactly what the alt is doing. If you can, you should get a wiring schematic for your car to better troubleshoot where the problem might be. At the risk of being too direct, the alternator does NOT feed the cig lighter socket! You could have a bad fuse panel or bad fuse or bad cable from the battery to the fuse panel. You could also have three problems and they mask the solution to the problem. Also remember that if the alternator sees an open load (or no load as in open wire) it will toast itself. One fun experiment might be to connect an extra load like a fog light to the alt output terminal and aim it so you could see it in the rear view mirror after you verify what the alt is at the terminal. That way if the connection all the way back to the battery had an open in it the alt would still see a load and the alt would output 14 volts (p=ie so i=p/e=55w/13v= 4.5amps). You are fighting a difficult problem. That which doesn't kill us makes us stronger. Good luck.

    Jeff Pintler
     
  14. AZLambo

    AZLambo Formula Junior

    Nov 4, 2003
    511
    Phoenix, AZ
    Full Name:
    Jeff
    Well, thanks everyone for your thoughts and suggestions, but I've had it with crawling under that damn F355. Removing an alternator with the car backed up on 7" ramps is a PITA.......not to mention claustraphobic!

    I have left it up to the.......gulp.....dealer to figure out. I was due for a major service anyway. While they have the engine out, they can check all the wiring. I told them I don't even want to look at that car again until the thing is fixed!!!!!

    Worn out..
    AZFerrari
     
  15. ernie

    ernie Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa Owner

    Nov 19, 2001
    22,620
    The Brickyard
    Full Name:
    The Bad Guy
    AAAAAAAHHH! Don't give up. You're gonna to have to go through the entire wiring and find where the problem is. Having the dealer do that is gonna cost you some retarded money, and they may not even find anything. If you really are at your wits end, then go get your car and take it to a good auto electric shop and have them trace the problem.
     
  16. Jeff Pintler

    Jeff Pintler Formula Junior

    Jul 20, 2005
    537
    Richland
    Full Name:
    Jeff Pintler
    Sorry we couldn't help you resolve this. My big splurge was a two post lift and it makes things alot more fun. The delco unit on the TR has one small wire for warning lamp and a large terminal for output (regulation is internal). The nippondenso (sp) unit on the 348 has one large wire to the starter, one small wire(1.5mm) to the bat warning lamp, one small wire to ignition switch (guessing run position) and one small wire all the way back to the battery (connector 85 on the schematic). Boy, I'd sure be tempted to make a small jumper for the "s" terminal (R color code) and connect it directly to the battery. AFTER CONNECTING A FUSED SMALL WIRE TO THE LARGE CABLE BETWEEN THE ALT AND THE STARTER to monitor the output voltage. Looks like there is also a five pin connector (called engine devices connector #115) that the S terminal cable passes through that could be corroded (the wires to the Battery warning lamp and to the ignition switch also pass through the same connector). Alot of times a connector with a poor connection will carry current for a short time, overheat and then loose connection. That is why I'm suggesting jumping the S terminal since the Bat warning lamp works. The "IG" terminal wire goes all the ignition switch (15b) and may have power when the key is in the run position. I would hate to think the previous alternators couldn't be tested properly because of two small wires that need power to charge the battery! Anyway, sorry we couldn't solve this one.
    Good Luck!

    Jeff Pintler
    Darn it!
     

Share This Page