F40 acceleration problems | FerrariChat

F40 acceleration problems

Discussion in 'Technical Q&A' started by HeavyR, Sep 12, 2014.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    #1 HeavyR, Sep 12, 2014
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    help !!! I am having a major headache with a poor running F40 non cat . to give you some back ground the car has done very liitle mileage in the last 5 years . we have carried out a major service including belts and fuel tanks, we are unsure how well it was running before it came to us as we we loathed to drive it hard as the belts hadnt been changed for 5 years !! also the fuel had gone bad . The problem occurs at around 4000rpm just as the boost comes in , it feels like you loose total power for about 3 seconds then a small splutter and you get full boost all the way to the limiter, i can produce this fault in any gear. we have checked the phase sensor air gap's , replaced the revolution sensors ,replaced the temp sensors, checked fuel pressure and delivery rate which is accurate to the workshop manual being 3 bar and 1.5 litres in 30 seconds, i have checked the fuel pressure regulators for fuel ingress into the vacuum pipes and checked their operation by applying vauum and pressure causing the fuel pressure to decrease and increase , the injectors have been asnu cleaned and given a clean bill of health. i have checked all vacuum lines and orifaces for blockages , i have checked the MAP sensors , I have swappeed the boost soleniod , checked the operation of the recirculation valves , checked and gapped the spark plugs . i have rigged up a external pressure gauge and checked we are not at overboost , the drop out of power seems to be at 0.8 bar . i have swapped ECU's from side to side to try and change the characteristics of the fault but still cant really make up my mind what it happening, with somebody following me on the road it appears to be both banks mifiring from what is happening at the tail pipes !!! this would probably be alot easier with a donor car but we havent got another one avaliable to us . the car does have a sports exhaust which i know can cause some problems , i have also taken the tops of the ECU's , i cant see anything unusual although i am not sure if the main chip is original or an uprated one , I have attached a picture .if anyone has any more idea's it would be a great help as i'm rapidly running out of them !!!!!
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  2. Cribbj

    Cribbj Formula 3

    I would spend some time going over the ignition system in your car. The only mention I see of ignition troubleshooting in your post is that you regapped your plugs. On a 20+ year old very high performance car like the F40, with an older traditional ignition system that uses HT wires, it should be one of the early suspects for poor running.

    You should go through the wires, and coils, looking for cracks, carbon spots, or other points of distress. Also measure the resistance of each of the wires to look for internal breakdowns. Measure the resistance of each coil as well. Put a timing light on each HT wire as the engine is running and check that it's flashing smoothly & regularly.

    If possible, and parts are available, I'd go ahead & replace the wires & coil on one bank of the engine and see if the issue improves, then do the other.

    Caveat: I am not a specialist on the F40 itself or its ignition system (I own a 550 Maranello), however I do know a few things about ignitions and boosted cars in general, and all boosted cars are VERY demanding on an ignition system.

    Your symptoms are typical of a weak spark that is being blown out at the onset of boost. This is the point of most stress for the engine and ignition, as you are looking for peak torque from the engine, and cylinder pressures have just dramatically increased with the turbochargers coming in and providing more air. A weak ignition cannot meet this demand.

    I can't say that the ignition is the root cause of your problem, but I can say that on a 20+ year old turbocharged car like the F40, it probably does need attention.
     
  3. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    Hi cribbj , thank you for your responce , we have tried a few things with the ignition, but it is incredibly hard to record good data for this fault on the road, i did try to scope the leads but at the on set of the fault the scope pattern goes a bit crazy so hard to tell what is really going on . i hear what you say about the spark blow out , that is the gutt feeling for us but without the donor parts will be hard to prove , F40 parts are becoming ridiculous in price but we may have to bite the bullet and swap out the coils , we have tested the ecu trigger signal and earth from the ecu's for the coils using a breakout box and the seem to be good, think i will revisit the igniton leads althought they look good , the car has only done 6000 miles although that doesnt mean anything with a part breaking down , it just seem odd as if one coil pack or one igniter or a lead or two were going down it surely would feel like a mis fire but this seems almost total loss of power or at least one bank switching off ??
     
  4. mechaniker

    mechaniker Formula Junior
    Owner

    May 30, 2004
    567
    Germany
    You said, that You just checked and gaped the spark plugs. REPLACE THEM!!!! Sometimes they get a problem and need to be replaced (don´t ask, i replaced a lot of spark plugs on our F40...).

    After that, check the sensors at the camshaft! They tend to rust away, the rev sensor generally makes no problem, but the phase sensors (again, don´t ask, i replaced 2 sets on the F40 and even more on the GTO...).

    And replace the exhaust with an original one! You have different backpressure and the mapping is just not made for this!

    Wish You luck to solve the problems.
     
  5. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    the plugs were replaced as part of the service , thought they may be the problem so as they were champion which i am not a big fan of , refitted the originals which were ngk and looked fine after a clean and regap , the phase sensors are in perfect condition , i to have seen these sensors in very poor condition , i have gapped them to 0.30mm and checked the signal with occiliscope which looked good and clean. i am tempted to get the original exhaust from the customer but i have been told it has run fine with the sports system although i do wondor why people think these cars need a upgraded system!!! thx for you thoughts on this problem ;-)
     
  6. sburke

    sburke Formula 3

    Dec 21, 2010
    1,273
    Lake Norman, NC
    Coils, injectors, fuel filter (As dumb as that sounds) Boost leak
     
  7. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    injectors have been asnu cleaned , the fuel filters were replaced and i also have bridged them out for test purposes toe eliminate. checked all hoses , cannot find any leaks of any sort !!!
     
  8. Cribbj

    Cribbj Formula 3

    The details I can find online about the F40's ignition is that you have twin, 2 tower coilpacks per bank and the 2 HT leads from each coilpack go to adjacent cylinders, which leads me to believe you may not have a waste spark ignition, depending of course, on the actual firing order of the engine and its cylinder numbering. Is the firing order the typical Ferrari V8 order of 1-5-3-7-4-8-2-6, and cylinder numbering (looking from flywheel) is 1-4 on the right bank, and 5-8 on left, with 1 & 8 being furthest from the flywheel and 4 & 5 being closest to the flywheel?

    In the interest of eliminating the ignition as the issue, I might pick up some cheap coils & HT leads just for testing, and see how they work out. Since you mentioned a possibly bad ignitor, I'm assuming they're external, and it sounds like you already know your way around an ignition, so I won't try to spoon feed you any of the basics :)

    If it were me, I'd probably try the temporary replacement ignition using Ford coilpacks and leads and see how it works. What's key is whether the existing setup is running in waste spark or not, as that will determine what type of temporary coilpacks you can try. (You could, of course, still try a pair of 4 tower Ford coilpacks on each bank, and only use 2 of the towers and shove silicone plugs into the "complementary" towers. Two of these and four leads would probably only set you back a hundred bucks or so.
     
  9. kverges

    kverges F1 Rookie

    Nov 18, 2003
    3,179
    Dallas
    Full Name:
    Keith Verges
    It seems unlikely to have an ignition problem due to malfunctioning coils, plugs or wires if the car runs at full boost and RPM, but not at just .8 bar and 4000 rpm. It sounds more like a problem at the onset of boost, and I'd wonder if the second set of injectors is not starting to fire properly. The basics are always fuel, spark and air, and you sure seem to have looked at these, but do all 16 injectors have good flow rates and spray patterns? As you also note I'd want to be sure the EEPROM is correct, but I can't help there.

    The mystery to me is that the car makes power at 1.5 bar and 7500 rpm as you describe it, but not at 0.8 bar and 4000 rpm. That tells me there is enough fuel and spark capacity, just an issue at the onset of boost. I'd want to put a wide band O2 sensor in the exhaust to see if there is a momentary lean condition that precedes the misfire.
     
  10. wrxmike

    wrxmike Moderator
    Moderator Owner

    Mar 20, 2004
    7,577
    Full Name:
    Mike
    I doubt the problem will be with the injectors or any of the fuel delivery system, because the engine can make full boost / power at high revs, where the demand on the fuel system is greatest.

    I also doubt the problem is in the ignition components either, as the greatest load on the ignition system is at high revs / load, and that seems to be ok too.

    I'd be focusing on the engine control systems, either the sensors feeding the data to the system, or a poorly remapped ecu. The fact that the problem is repeatable and occours at the same point strongly suggests a control or sensor problem

    The previus suggestion of a wideband O2 sensor to check for leanout is good,
    In the absence of spare ecu's to test, I would also try to plot the boost / vs revs and ignition timing vs revs to see if that matches the factory specs. That should give you a clue if the ECU has been remapped.

    Has anything been done to the turbos ? Different a/r ratio, housings, wastegate etc?
     
  11. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    #11 HeavyR, Sep 13, 2014
    Last edited: Sep 13, 2014
    I will answer some of the posted suggestions here in one go . It won't be the onset of the second set of injectors as they are triggered simultaneously at all times so the pair of injectors basically operate as one on each cylinder . The flow rate and spray pattern is good and even on all the injectors now as we have a report from the servicing agent . The car has what appears to be standard turbos which are giving about 1.2 bar maximum boost which is the workshop manual specification I am keen to explore cribbj's theory about spark blow out which makes sence to me ,I think I may try some cheap coils and leads and see if I can change the fault !! to add to that post the F40 does run wasted spark , each ecu has two ignition signals going to a pair if igniters then to a pair of 2 pole coils , the ecu supply's a common ground to each pair of igniters which we have scoped to see if it is switching out as the fault occurs . I am wondering if a faulty knock sensor could cause this problem ?? Not quite sure how I'm going to test this though without swapping it out and they are well buried !! Thank you for everyone's input , it is giving me some food for thought .
     
  12. Cribbj

    Cribbj Formula 3

    #12 Cribbj, Sep 13, 2014
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    I couldn't tell from the 1st diagram below if the engine had waste spark ignition, as it was difficult to follow each of the leads, however if one of your coilpacks is feeding cyl's 1&4 and the other is feeding 2&3, then it's certainly waste spark. The only thing that still gives me doubt is the ignitor module itself in the 2nd pic below. This "module" is nothing more than 2 Bosch 2 channel ignitors packaged on a heatsink, however according to the parts list, the engine requires 2 of these modules (1 for each bank), which would indicate to me, there's a need for 4 separate ignition outputs per bank, UNLESS as you say, the ECU on each side is only outputting 2 channels, and they've paralleled these ignitors at their inputs, in order to get longer dwell and more current capability at the output? I've done this on my bench simulator for a 550 ignition and it does produce a hotter spark.

    But if you're sure it's waste spark, then it'll only take a single 4 tower coilpack to feed each bank, and a standard Ford V8 EDIS/coilpack setup from any of their 90's cars should work fine, temporarily, and shouldn't cost more than $100 to $125 total. Cheap test and probably would be a better ignition than what's on there now.

    I'd also pick up a few of those Bosch 2 channel ignitors (0 227 100 200) just to be safe, but I'm sure you've already thought of that.

    This would be a fun car to upgrade to a COP ignition and possibly a CDI type COP setup, and it would clean up the engine bay a lot :) Not the sort of thing for a purist, but if your owner is a hotrodder...... :) :) :) If you're interested, drop me a PM; my V12 ignitions are running on 10-12 550's now (one of which is tracked regularly over in the UK), and I've helped a couple of owners sort out their 348/355 COP setups.
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  13. brian.s

    brian.s F1 Rookie
    Professional Ferrari Technician

    Nov 3, 2003
    3,806
    Midwest
    Full Name:
    Brian
    Someone else might chime in on this, but way back when these came out, installing an exhaust without enough back pressure would spool turbos too fast for the engine mapping and the exact problem you describe would occur. There was some black art retuning available which overcame the problem. Similar issues can be replicated on porsche TTs for similar reasons, electronic remaps cure those.
     
  14. don_xvi

    don_xvi F1 Rookie

    Nov 1, 2003
    2,934
    Outside Detroit
    Full Name:
    Don the 16th
    So far I don't see clearly if it's boost-related or RPM-related. If you creep the revs up at light throttle so you're not coming on the boost at 4000 RPM, does the problem still happen? What about if you're running over 5000 at light throttle and go WOT?
     
  15. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    On light throttle the problem does not seem to occur and also if driven hard at high rpm you can stay above the problem . It is most evident when you are trying to accelerate hard from around 2000rpm
     
  16. brian.s

    brian.s F1 Rookie
    Professional Ferrari Technician

    Nov 3, 2003
    3,806
    Midwest
    Full Name:
    Brian
    When the turbos spool up very quick, showing overboost to the wastegate and computers. The result is a brief very violent shutdown
     
  17. Rifledriver

    Rifledriver Three Time F1 World Champ

    Apr 29, 2004
    34,091
    Austin TX
    Full Name:
    Brian Crall
    Yep.

    Common problem. We ripped our hair out over that back when they came out.
     
  18. 335s

    335s Formula Junior

    Jan 17, 2007
    870
    SF Bay Area
    Full Name:
    T. Monma
    is this a PD algorithm/duty cycle controlled waste gate-a-la-USA catalyzed versions...or...is it early NON-cat with 3 "flat" exhaust pipes to rear of car a-la-288GTO..is so, THAT waste gate is THE SAME as a 288, same p/n as I recall...

    if this car has a proportional derivative algorithm driving a duty cycle...ANY change in back pressure adversely affect back pressure and the system can't bleed off the faster rate of change in the rate of change of boost ONSET(second derivative) to deal with this, the waste gate must be modified internally. A minor bore from 1/2 to 1mm in a line, etc, etc...
    This is NOT a well understood area of modification on these cars and it really is difficult to deal with over the internet without even understanding what is baseline configuration...
    perhaps some more detailed pics of the exhaust and turbo stuff? This is a slightly more detailed version of the esteemed shooter's explanation, however, it does really-IMO-applies more or less ONLY to cat versions-regardless of country of delivery, as the "cold bag" section is all that is really different within the "map".
     
  19. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    We have now fitted the original exhaust back on to the car , although the fault is slightly improved it is definately still present . Have also swapped out all the ignition modules and have checked the resistance of the ignition leads which were all around 5 Kohms so all within spec. Got some coils coming to try. After that think we have pretty much checked or swapped most things now !! We are going to borrow another F40 and may be swap the ecu's , what else is left !!!
     
  20. mechaniker

    mechaniker Formula Junior
    Owner

    May 30, 2004
    567
    Germany
    Can You see, if the Wastegate was manipulated?

    It more or less is set to a specific opening pressure and acts mechanically. Than You have an electric bleeding valve unter the right Airbox. Check this! (A friend brought an F40 with a broken Wastegate and bleeding valve. He had massive problems)

    Maybe someone manipulated the wastegate to go around replacing the bleeding vale. The bleeding Valve is easy to check: do You hear a "click" when the ignition turns on/off?
     
  21. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    i have already replaced the waste gate control valve as i have mentioned at the start of the thread , i have tried winding the screw out a couple of turns to release the pressure on the waste gate spring and therefore dropping the boost pressure, i have an external boost gauge plummed in at the moment and it shows that the problem occors at 0.8 bar which is well below overboost, with the control valve disconnected the car will accelerate through the problem with more of a hesitation rather than the total loss of power you feel with it connected but with a considerable drop in power which may be just masking the fault , may be i need to swap out the complete waste gate ?? the car has been sat for quite a while so may be something is not functioning correctly within it ??
     
  22. mechaniker

    mechaniker Formula Junior
    Owner

    May 30, 2004
    567
    Germany
    Also can be. I just replaced two broken Wastegate Membranes. You can test it by applying pressure to the Wastegate and see, if it leaks. If not, remove the Wastegate completely and check for free movement. DON`T OPEN now as it can destroy the membrane!

    Only open if the membrane is split!

    Sorry to advice You to check the valve, it is hard to read Your snail-text and remember everything :)
     
  23. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    sorry mechaniker , i've tried to include every detail , even i have forgotten what ive done and writen down !!!
     
  24. HeavyR

    HeavyR Rookie

    Jan 31, 2012
    42
    Devon
    Full Name:
    harvey jones
    big thanks to mechaniker , the membrane does appear to be leaking , this fault has sent us round in circles although still confused by the syptoms, we were expecting either the vehicle to be in overboost and bringing the light on or a lack of power due to reduced waste gate performance , strange symtoms !!!! will get the waste gate serviced up and repost the results.
     
  25. mechaniker

    mechaniker Formula Junior
    Owner

    May 30, 2004
    567
    Germany
    #25 mechaniker, Sep 19, 2014
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    Than open it.

    You than will understand the symptoms. The membrane is pushed against a piston and the Wastegate Housing under pressure. When the crack/hole is neither on the piston or Wastegate Housing, You will have a leak. (Hope, You understand what i tryed to describe...)


    Picture is from a 288 GTO Wastegate, but it is very similar (GTO is pressurised by exhaust gasses, F40 by charged air)
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     

Share This Page