My struggles with (possible) Ferrari ownership | FerrariChat

My struggles with (possible) Ferrari ownership

Discussion in 'New Member Introductions' started by chicago_c, Mar 8, 2010.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    Hello all,

    I've been lurking fchat for a while, and decided to post for the first time to get some insights on what I've been internally struggling with. The discussion in this other thread (http://www.ferrarichat.com/forum/showthread.php?t=276164) was interesting to me, and encouraged me to start this thread.

    Some background:
    I live in Chicago, in my early 30's, and love cars. Most people here seem pretty hardcore, so in that crowd I'm not sure I would qualify as a "true" car lover - for example, I haven't been to any performance driving school classes, I don't know my way around extensively under the hood, etc. However, I still do really enjoy and appreciate cars and driving, and by most normal standards would be considered a car nut. I think we all have certain cars that are special to us, and for me that car is the Ferrari F360 / F430. For whatever reason, these cars evoke a unique emotional response in my heart like no other car, something I can't explain. I would rather drive a F430 than any other exotic - 599, Veyron, etc... not that I've ever driven any of them to compare & know, but that is how I feel. I really like the look of the new 458 as well, although it is not "special" to me in quite the same way as the 430.

    I currently drive an E92 M3, which I love. I've been extremely fortunate in my career over the past decade. For the past few years, I've been at a point where spending $300k on a dream car, financially speaking, is a total non-issue. So why haven't I bought a F430 already?

    My struggles:
    1.
    My biggest issue, first and foremost, is the social cost of owning and driving a Ferrari. For better or worse, my wife and I have made the life decision to hide our wealth as much as possible from our friends & family. We have structured our lives in such a way that our entire social circle believes, for the most part, that we are of similar means as they are. This comes at some cost, as there have been many decisions where we would prefer to do one thing, but in order to maintain this appearance, we must do another thing. Thus far, this trade off has been more than worth it to us. Buying a F430 is one of the things that I cannot do in order to maintain this appearance.

    It's not necessarily the money - for example, in my social circle, buying a $125k new S-class would be acceptable (although it would be pushing it). However, buying a $125k 2005 F430 would not be acceptable, since for better or worse, it is just perceived differently. Ironic, because the new S-class would actually depreciate more quickly, but that is how it is.

    So this is a huge struggle of mine. Do I buy it, but then keep it secret and only drive it on weekends where I'm sure I won't be seen? Or do I only take it to the track? Or do I just say eff it, social costs be damned, just buy it? etc.

    2.
    Although financially I can afford the car no problem, I still do not like to waste money or pay more for something than I have to. Buying a new(er) Ferrari and losing 50% to depreciation over 3 years is something that I struggle with. Especially in Chicago, I ask myself how many miles I really would be able to put on it per year, and whether that's worth the tens of thousands of dollars per year it would cost me in depreciation. One way around this is to buy an older one where the depreciation curve has flattened to a good degree, and that's why I mention the 2005 F430 above... that's something I've been keeping my eye on. I realize this question of "worth" is entirely personal and nobody else can answer it for me, but I thought perhaps other Ferrari owners who have struggled with the same thing might be able to contribute some insights.

    My plan:
    I oscillate between "The social costs and the depreciation costs are just too high, I can't get a Ferrari" and "Screw that, life is short, just buy the damn car you love it so much." Some days I question if bending over backwards to maintain appearances is really worth it - not that we've really had to bend over backwards too much, we do live very comfortable lives. But I do wonder how much bending over is too much, not just because of the Ferrari question but for other future situations that I'm sure will arise. Again, a very personal question, but I'm sure there are others here that have faced similar questions.

    For the time being, I've been monitoring used F430 prices, educating myself by reading up on fchat, etc. It seems like the 2008+ is the way to go for F430's... I guess my default plan as of now is to wait a couple years until the 2008's come down in price to a flatter part of the curve, and then think about buying it at that time. I don't know if this is me just putting off the decision - rather than buying a 2006 now. It does seem like the equation might change a bit once the 458 actually comes out, so I guess I'm "waiting" for that as well. The plan would be to keep it a secret, and try to just drive it at times / places where I'm very sure I won't be spotted, however I wonder if that's really feasible. For example, when our friends come over, are we just not going to let them see the garage? etc.

    That's it, thanks for reading, I would appreciate any thoughts you guys have.
     
  2. Jedi

    Jedi Moderator
    Moderator Lifetime Rossa Owner

    Mar 18, 2008
    32,160
    Seattle Area
    Full Name:
    Dave
    That would be my choice (and was my choice). If your friends can't understand it or
    alienate you - you need new friends.

    Welcome to F-Chat!

    Jedi
     
  3. greyboxer

    greyboxer F1 World Champ

    Dec 8, 2004
    12,628
    South East
    Full Name:
    Jimmie
    Is it not possible that your peer group might be happy for you for your success ?
     
  4. g4titan

    g4titan Formula 3
    Owner

    Feb 6, 2010
    1,196
    Around
    Full Name:
    Nico
    I have kind of the same friend scenario as you describe. I'll be 32 in May and the notion of me having this car around my friend circle is a little nutty and get people spun up in ways it's not worth chatting about. But in the end I pulled the trigger and keep her quiet in the garage. I fire her up and I've been trying to drive the paint off of her ever since albeit only a couple of weeks now :) If I have to go to a wine dinner of sorts I just take the less pointed car over and all is good.

    The depreciation aspect is a whole different story. I don't think you should look at is as such but rather an investment in your life especially if this car is your dream machine. You don't want to be the richest man in the grave! pull the trigger!
     
  5. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    greyboxer,
    It depends, and the situation is not entirely clear-cut or simple. There certainly are people who would be nothing but happy for me, proud of me, etc. (A couple of my very closest friends, for example. But then these friends already know everything about my situation, and I'm having these same conversations re: Ferrari ownership with them.) Then there are other people who I'm fairly confident might judge me, they don't understand that a Ferrari is magical to me, feel that the money would be better spent elsewhere, etc. (Including in-laws and other family members.) Then there are others who wouldn't judge me and might even be happy for me, but at the same time the car (and what it implies) may be a wedge in the relationship (mostly acquaintences, not close friends). Then there are the people I don't know very well, like my neighbors etc., and I fear how the car might alter my interactions with them.

    A lot of the above is speculation on my part, since I don't know for 100% fact that owning a Ferrari would in fact alter my interactions with my neighbors (although I very strongly suspect that this would be the case). That's mostly what I'm hoping to learn in this thread from the people on this forum... Also, even assuming that the above groups of people would think negatively of me, it's a fair question how much I care about this. I'm not sure there is a simple answer to that. I am definitely not one to people-please and just do what others think I should do, in fact for most of my life I've been the exact opposite (going out of my way to stick out). However, in recent years, I have also learned the value of making peace whenever possible and not creating unnecessary confrontations (my wife's influence...). So, I do care to a fair extent (whatever that means), to not have my in-laws judge me even if I feel that their judgment is incorrect or undeserved. Again, I do realize that this is a highly personal question.


    g4titan,
    Congrats on your recent purchase! Just so I'm clear: do you keep your Ferrari a strict secret, like how I'm planning on doing? Or is it not secret, but just something that you don't advertise? Have you been "discovered" yet by anybody who you don't want to be discovered by?

    Re: your point about depreciation, I'm mostly with you. Really, the social cost is the vast majority of my hold up, and I think I'm using $$$ (depreciation) as an excuse to not go through with it. I will tell you this much, if the social cost somehow magically disappeared right now, I would go out and buy a 2009 F430 immediately. I do know that much.
     
  6. marioz

    marioz Formula 3

    Nov 21, 2003
    2,025
    Cedar Mills,Ontario
    Full Name:
    Mario
    chicago_c

    does not sound like you are ready for the Ferrari by the questions that you ask
     
  7. acuransx20001

    acuransx20001 Karting

    May 19, 2005
    223
    Redwood City
    Full Name:
    Abraham
    Stop worrying about what others may think. Ultimitely, it's your life. Are you going to let your dream escape you because you're worried how others may perceive you?
     
  8. Devilsolsi

    Devilsolsi F1 Veteran
    Rossa Subscribed

    Mar 1, 2007
    9,168
    MD
    Full Name:
    Alex
    If you are that worried about perception, get something less flashy. A 911 turbo would be a lot of car for you, but are common enough that no one else would think twice. There are plenty of awesome cars out there that you could get, while remaining low key.

    My opinion is, if a car purchase is enough to upset your friends, they aren't really your friends in the first place..
     
  9. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    You may very well be 100% correct, but I'm wondering: what do you mean by the questions that I ask? I (perhaps incorrectly) imagined that the social costs and the actual dollar costs are factors that many Ferrari owners analyzed and thought hard about. Perhaps their answer was "Yes, it's definitely worth it," but you're saying that even by asking the questions, I must not be ready for the Ferrari?

    I'm just here to learn from the experiences of others who maybe went through the same thought processes & struggles as I am.
     
  10. raider1968

    raider1968 F1 Rookie
    Owner

    Mar 13, 2008
    4,966
    NC Mnts & Asheville
    Full Name:
    John E
    You need to get a life and think for yourself
     
  11. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    I hear you, and that's where my E92 M3 came from... That was to be my less flashy daily driver that doesn't upset my friends, and I do love that car. But I keep coming back to the F430 over and over again, week after week and month after month. It has constantly been on my mind, off and on, for years and years. There is no other car that comes even close in my book, not the 911 turbo or any other car.
     
  12. nathandarby67

    nathandarby67 F1 Veteran
    Owner

    Feb 1, 2005
    8,349
    Mississippi
    Full Name:
    Nathan
    I say spend less time worrying about what other people think and more time driving your new Ferrari.

    Ask yourself this: when you are old and feeble and living in a wheelchair in the nursing home and eating pudding for supper, will you be wishing you had spent more time making sure the neighbors and in-laws had a good opinion of you, or wishing you had just bought the damn car you love and spent that time taking long drives in the country with your wife? I also agree with the other posters, if people suddenly start to treat you badly because you bought a certain kind of car, they were not anyone you want to be associated with in the first place.

    I also think the car will have less of a "social impact" than you might imagine. It has certainly been that way for me and several others I know.
     
  13. JoeZaff

    JoeZaff F1 Veteran
    Owner

    Aug 5, 2007
    5,459
    Philly suburbs
    Full Name:
    Joe
    I think your making this a bit to heavy. My neighbors are very conservative salt of the earth good people. I love them all. Believe me, as the youngest guy in my neighborhood, tooling around in a Ferrari irked people. However, I try to be a nice guy, help out anyone with anything from shoveling the walk to legal issues and I don't make a big thing about anything I own. If people ask, I tell them this has been a life long passion of mine and I decided to make the lifestyle adjustments to make it happen.


    If you want a Ferrari...if it brings a burning passion to you and sets your world on fire, then you don't need reassurance...you know what you have to do. However, if you are on the fence, are worried about what the neighbors will think, the bug probably hasn't bit you hard enough, and it won't be long before maintenance costs, depreciation, jealousy etc spoil the experience for you. We've all been nervous about pulling the trigger, and concocted every sort of reason why not. However, if I have learned anything, it is that a Ferrari is not a decision that should be subject to rational thought or a pros and cons list...that's what Porsches are for ;)


    Just remember, as I often say, in the pantheon of great automobiles, there is Ferrari, and then there is everything else...if you have the means, what category do you want to be in :) The clock is ticking...
     
  14. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    JoeZaff,
    Thank you for your perspective. Your comment about "the bug probably hasn't bit you hard enough," I never looked at it that way before and that's something for me to go and think about. Your post really does make me question if I'm ready for the Ferrari, as I can totally see myself looking at maintenance costs, jealousy etc. and thinking to myself that this totally isn't worth it. (On the other hand, I can also see myself being on the fence for a couple more years, finally pull the trigger, and kick myself for not pulling the trigger sooner...) Definitely something for me to think about.

    nathandarby67,
    It's helpful to hear that for you, there's been less social impact than you imagined. Certainly a data point for me to keep in mind.
     
  15. BLAMPEE

    BLAMPEE Man Card Status: Never Issued

    I'm angry.

    Life is too short to give a rats A$$ about what your neighbors/friends "think" of you for spekding money on something that YOU deserve because you save/live frugally/or just plain work your tail off.

    Besides...it doesn't matter if you buy a 308 versus a 430...those people you are so concerned about are going to see the pretty little prancing pony and automatically think whatever they want. These cars don't have a numerical value to those not in the know. You'd be surprised at how many strangers ask if my 1999 355 is brand new.

    Buy the car that makes you feel like your a schoolboy who got his first G.I. Joe action figure and can't wait to take it outside and play "war."
     
  16. marioz

    marioz Formula 3

    Nov 21, 2003
    2,025
    Cedar Mills,Ontario
    Full Name:
    Mario
    For ME a Ferrari sells itself.

    1. The fact that you do not want to show your success to your friends rules out the Ferrari. I do not understand why anyone would do this but that is your choice & I respect that. Like other have said you only live once & if you really want something & can afford it F*** what everyone else may think. (I am curious though on your reasoning for the coverup--sounds like you are passing up on things you & your wife like to do).

    2. The depreciation factor should be a non issue in my mind. It is is what it is & the cost is not cheap. If that is a big issue with you shop around to find a GOOD used car that has already depreciated. If you really want to play it safe you may want to consider 308/328/348/355 or a Testa Rossa. Or buy a new 458 & flip it before it depreciates--I have seen guys make money being the first to get a car & sell it when demand is at it's highest.

    3. The amount of driving should not be a factor & if you have a low milege car it will be a benefit when you decide to sell it.

    My advice to you is to take as many types of Ferraris as you can for a test drive. You should also consider renting one for a weekend. This should answer your question of weather you are ready to buy a Ferrari. If you can't get the smile off your face --YOU ARE READY.

    Don't forget Ferraris sell themselves & the hell with everyone else.

    PS you may find that you have more friends once you have the Ferrari.

    Hope this helps. Good luck in whatever you decide.
     
  17. caponome

    caponome Rookie

    Dec 30, 2009
    34
    When I got my 308 about 30 years ago, I kept a very low profile with it. I didn't hide it from my friends, they knew my passion and were excited for me. If you have the passion for this automobile, then you have a sense of what many of the people on this site already know. This is the finest combination of art and engineering that has ever graced the road. If you can afford it, desire it, and still deny yourself this experience, you are either a fool or you have other issues to deal with.

    Two things to keep in mind, reward your success you deserve it, and never bring a Ferrari to divorce court. :)
     
  18. Rifledriver

    Rifledriver Three Time F1 World Champ

    Apr 29, 2004
    36,769
    Cowboy Capitol of the World
    Full Name:
    Brian Crall
    I know a number of people that are much like the person you describe yourself as. The few of them that have bought the car were very unhappy. Everyone is different, no big deal but I think you need to find a car that fits your needs. A Ferrari ain't it.
     
  19. yelcab

    yelcab F1 World Champ
    Consultant

    Nov 29, 2001
    13,398
    San Carlos, CA
    Full Name:
    Mitchell Le
    Nobody on their death beds would say ..."I am happy I made all those low key compromises to keep my neighbors happy."
     
  20. Texas Forever

    Texas Forever Eight Time F1 World Champ
    Rossa Subscribed

    Apr 28, 2003
    85,557
    Texas!
    Listen to da man.

    There are only two reasons for buying a Ferrari: (1) You want to, and (2) You can.

    Trust me, it is not a rational decision.

    You didn't say, or I didn't see, how you plan on using the car. Are you a Sunday morning back roads kind of guy, or do you want to cruise the strip on your way to a titty bar, or do you plan on attending FCA rallies, or do you plan on parking the car in your garage and looking at it while sipping an adult beverage and smoking a cigar?

    The point is to have fun. If you're going to be worried about the cost, I'd suggest a Porsche or a Lotus.

    For me personally, the funny thing is I found Ferrari people to be a lot more interesting than the cars. Imagine that.

    Dale

    PS Don't worry about your neighbors. Sooner or later, they will figure out that you are crazier than bat**** anyway.

    PPS If you do buy, F430s are one hell of a deal.
     
  21. jsa330

    jsa330 F1 World Champ
    Silver Subscribed

    Oct 31, 2003
    10,026
    75225
    Full Name:
    Scott
    I have to compare the money I've spent on Ferraris against what other guys of some extra means do with their money.

    Some play golf....big bucks club memberships, etc.

    Some hunt and fish...you that's cheap, check again

    Some fly small airplanes. Not cheap.

    One friend has an acoustic guitar collection worth what my 308 is, and adds to it periodically.

    Point is that I know guys who do the above things. When one of them tells me that I must be a millionaire "because" I have a Ferrari, I point out the expense involved in his particular hobby. That shuts them up.

    As far as people with kids in college laying on the guilt trip, I tell them that nobody held a gun to their heads when it came to the actions necessary for conception. That is also an effective silencer of self-righteous criticism.

    Every owner here had to pull that same trigger at some point. It's harder for some. I'd say buy the car and enjoy it. You'll regret not doing it and also find out who your real friends are.
     
  22. g4titan

    g4titan Formula 3
    Owner

    Feb 6, 2010
    1,196
    Around
    Full Name:
    Nico
    boom... hit the nail on the head! My closest friends now know that I have a Ferrari tucked in the garage for a nice weather drive...

    Someone mentioned that you shouldn't get one based on your questions, total nonsense. I think the reality is that subtle people don't need to advertise what they wear, what kind of wine they drink, what kind of watch the have on or what kind of car they drive. It's about making a comfortable conversation with everyone in the room. I get that some people live to flash but I think the majority of people like to enjoy something that they deserve without pushing it down someone else's throat.

    If someone notices that you have that nice watch on or are rocking that Ferrari it's because they discovered it not that you jammed it in their face and parked it on their front lawn.

    I think that at the end of the day your closest friends will get the passion that you have behind your ride. I enjoy showing it to the people that know me best versus the passer bys that may form a disjointed opinion on my situation.

    Drive her hard and have fun!
     
  23. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    I'm really intrigued by this, as this is something that kind of occurred to me in the back of my mind. Could you elaborate on what exactly made your friends unhappy? Was it the maintenance cost / hassle, was it the social cost, was it that they realized that they simply weren't ultra into Ferrari's, etc.?
     
  24. chicago_c

    chicago_c Rookie

    Mar 8, 2010
    20
    Chicago, IL
    Dr Who,

    I would restrict my use of the car to situations where I can remain anonymous... So basically, this will likely mean weekend drives when the weather is nice, or possibly weekday drives at night. Likely, I won't be driving it more than a handful of times a month tops, especially during the non-summer months here in Chicago. Just having one in my garage to look at every day, like you said, would be a huge source of joy to me.

    I agree that the point is fun. I would for sure have lots of fun with this car. Just trying to figure out if it's worth the social cost that I imagine would be associated with it... People in this thread have already pointed out that the social cost is likely smaller than what I imagine, and I appreciate the feedback. The monetary cost is not a serious factor, even though I listed it in my OP as one of two factors... it is 95% the social cost for me.

    Thanks for your comments. I seem to be getting a common thread here that getting a Ferrari isn't a rational decision :) That might be my problem here, is that generally speaking I'm an ultra rational person and tend to analyze everything to the death.
     
  25. JoeZaff

    JoeZaff F1 Veteran
    Owner

    Aug 5, 2007
    5,459
    Philly suburbs
    Full Name:
    Joe
    #25 JoeZaff, Mar 8, 2010
    Last edited: Mar 8, 2010
    TRUST ME...YOU ARE OVERANALYZING THIS!!!! Don't force yourself into a false choice. You are a young guy, who knows what the future holds. Hopefully, there will be a future time to revisit this when owning a Ferrari is more consistent with your other priorities. It doesn't mean you are a bad person or not a true car nut, it just means you have decided to take a more reasonable, practical route. There are tons of cars out there that will fit your niche (think Corvette/Porsche/BMW). When you get a real case of the red mist, make flat crank engine sounds in the shower and dream about looking down at the prancing horse on the steering wheel, you will be ready.

    Buying a Ferrari requires the same mental commitment as putting all your chips on seven. You are either all in, damn the consequences, or you buy something else.

    Good luck!
     

Share This Page