New York City insurance question

Hi everybody - quick question - I used to keep my Boxer in Ct. and paid 1500/yr for complete coverage, and now that I keep it in Brooklyn they want 3000/ yr - Geico. The classic-car insurance companies seem to need one car per licensed driver in addition to the collector car in order to qualify for their coverage....anyway, who are you guys using and who would you reccomend I try as this rate seems ridiculous for a car I keep under lock and key and drive maybe 1500 miles a year. I have a clean record, no moving violations in the last 10 years....thanks for your help in advance. John