TR Clutch Assessment - Help Needed | FerrariChat

TR Clutch Assessment - Help Needed

Discussion in 'Technical Q&A' started by cgperry, May 22, 2005.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    #1 cgperry, May 22, 2005
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2017
    My car is a 1987 Euro Swiss TR, #73795. It has 43k miles on it, 38k+ of that is on this clutch. First clutch was replaced at about 4500 miles before I bought the car. It should have the later clutch package for TRs.

    The symptoms are that the car, over time, has become increasingly difficult to get into gear. It will go, but you feel like you have to overcome a significant mechanical resistance to seat the next gear. At one time I had a shifter alignment problem that my mechanic fixed, so I took it back to him again. He informed me that the alignment was ok and that the clutch was shot. So yesterday I disassembled the clutch mechanism with the intention of verifying which clutch it had before ordering parts. This is my first time doing a clutch on a TR, so I need some help.

    What concerns me is that when I took the old two clutch discs out, they are both measuring .305” thickness, or 7.747mm. According to the shop manual, they should be 8.2mm new with 1.2mm of maximum wear. That means my car is only about 38% through the maximum clutch life.

    Is this a normal amount of wear before you get significantly harder shifting, or should I be looking for something other than clutch causing my problem? I don’t want to dump $3k of parts into the car only to find out it was something else. The discs are worn very evenly, although there are some coloration differences in the plates (see pictures). There is also significant wear on the back of the pressure plate, but I’m not sure if that ‘notch’ is normal or worn along with the throw-out bearing.

    There was no chattering or slipping that I could feel on this clutch. I tried putting it in a high gear and hitting the gas hard and did not see the tach jump more than the speedometer or feel any hesitation.

    If this clutch is still good, I made the mistake of not marking the alignment of all the discs, so I’m not sure if I could put them back in correctly balanced. I do have a bunch of digital photos to use, but how crucial is balance if I reinstall the same clutch?
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
    Image Unavailable, Please Login
     
  2. henryk

    henryk Formula Junior

    Dec 9, 2003
    479
    Door County, WI
    The notch is from a worn throw-out bearing..........pressure plate rides on "sticking" bearing, causing the groove. I had this in my TR, but the bearing made noise..........yours will too eventually. I would replace the bearing.

    I would re-install the clutch, however, leave out the 6 washers (spacers). This will put the clutch discs closer together, and tighter. Why wait till they slip. This will give you more life from the clutch.

    Alignment is simple. Find the 'H" letter, written in white, on each disc, and assemble them where the "H" is 180 degrees apart between the two discs. The "H" stands for "heavy" side of the disc. The other parts are balanced individually, so they can go together regardless where placed, in relation to the other parts.

    My guess would be that you have another gear alignment problem????????.........possibly wearing synchros?????????

    Good luck!
     
  3. matteo

    matteo F1 World Champ

    Aug 1, 2002
    13,748
    On a plane somewhere
    Full Name:
    Heir Butt
    It sounds like alignment. How does it shift about 5k rpm? If it is still hard?

    Put the car in 5th gear at idle. Let out the clutch, If it stalls, it's an alignment or synchros. If it slips, it's the clutch.
     
  4. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    Thanks Henry. If the groove is already as shown, should I replace the pressure plate too?

    Still wondering what "normal" disc thickness should be for a clutch needing replacement...
     
  5. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    How easy, or not easy, was it to get the clutch discs off of the spline? Full disengagement requires that both clutch disc hubs move a little along the length of the spline when the pressure plate moves away from the flywheel. If the primary symptom was:

    stationary
    running in neutral with the clutch pedal up
    push clutch pedal down
    can't select a forward gear (with 1st maybe being worse than 3rd)

    then I'd vote for just lack of lubrication on the spline (BTDT). If the parts are within their useable dimensions, I don't see any reason why you can't reuse them (but I'd replace the pilot and throw-out bearings and rebuild the slave cylinder if it's been more than ~10 years).

    Had very similar conditions at my first major (32K miles total and 12 years) -- about 60% left on the discs, very dry throw-out bearing, and a rusty spline with a frozen clutch hub -- been working much, much better since relubing.
     
  6. henryk

    henryk Formula Junior

    Dec 9, 2003
    479
    Door County, WI
    I would not replace the pressure plate. This is only replaced when new clutch discs are installed, and the flywheel resurfaced........IMO. The discs, flywheel surface, inner plate and pressure plate should be done together, when new discs are needed.

    I would replace the discs only if I see the slanted slots at a minimal depth.........seen on both surfaces of the disc. I you could see all slots, then leave it alone. If the slots are gone, then the disc will gouge out grooves in the flywheel, which will need repalcing............expensive, I think!!!!!!
     
  7. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    Steve -

    What do you use to lubricate the spline? In my case the spline came out with the bellhousing as shown. It took some prying to get the bellhousing off (partially because of sealant used at bottom around input shaft), but the discs seem to slide off easily once we freed the bellhousing. As you can see, though, the spline was dry and somewhat rusty.
     
  8. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    I didn't mean lubricate in the sense of applying a significant amount of grease -- it's not an area where you want a lot of grease flinging about. More a process of cleaning up the loose rust dust and then wiping down the steel surfaces of the spline and clutch hubs with a thin grease film so they don't rust so quickly from atmospheric moisture (think "like doing a wax job to the paintwork", but just with a grease instead of a wax).

    Any general-purpose chassis grease would be OK IMO.
     
  9. Frank R. Masiarz

    Nov 10, 2003
    126
    Full Name:
    Frank R. Masiarz
    Hi.........

    Ninety-oneTR is absolutlely right about the lubrication.

    Look at the pictures of the input shaft and the splines. Rust and/or dust on everything !!! There must be free movement, even if it is ever so slight, to allow the clutch discs to disengage from the flywheel during shift action.

    Clean up every part with compressed air....and wear a mask.

    Check the Ferrari TR workshop manual for recommendations for routine clutch service....or a great mechanic.

    Frank.....23005
     
  10. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    Clutch discs came off very easily, so I don't think there was much binding. I'll still clean things up well when reassembling.

    I know about the throw-out bearing. Can you tell me where the pilot bearing is? Is that the one that's about on the center of the clutch shaft? There's a part in the parts manual there that just says 'bearing'.

    Also, location of the slave cylinder? The one in the front of the car says Clutch Master Cylinder in the parts book. No cylinders mentioned in the back section. In fact, I'm a little confused about what the hydraulic line actuates in the clutch housing. From looking at the exploded diagram it's not clear where it's creating pressure. Any good explanations?

    Henry - the discs do have an H marking the heavy point as you said, but so does the pressure plate. How should I align them? I think my pictures will show me but haven't tried yet.

    Also, what holds all the pieces of the clutch together until you can screw down the pressure plate? Is that what the Ferrari Clutch Alignment Tool is for? And then I assume when you remove it all the pieces stay aligned so you can put the clutch housing back on?

    Thanks for all the help! Learning to work on this beast is one of the fun parts.
     
  11. Steve Magnusson

    Steve Magnusson Two Time F1 World Champ
    Lifetime Rossa

    Jan 11, 2001
    26,932
    30°30'40" N 97°35'41" W (Texas)
    Full Name:
    Steve Magnusson
    The pilot bearing is the ball-bearing mounted in the end of the crankshaft (it receives that small diameter spud on the end of the clutch shaft). It will be on the SPC page that shows the crankshaft and flywheel (not the clutch stuff).

    I don't have my TR SPC with me so I can't comment directly now, but one thing that may be confusing is that part of the hydraulic path is built into the clutch housing IIRC (i.e., the hydraulic hose attaches to the clutch housing which has internal passages that eventually convey the fluid to the slave cylinder chamber).
     
  12. henryk

    henryk Formula Junior

    Dec 9, 2003
    479
    Door County, WI
    Charles: I would align the "H", on the discs 180 degrees apart from each other, as stated. Then, I would place these at a 90 degree angle to the "H" on the pressure plate. Make sure there isn't an "H" on the middle steel disc........if so, then align it at 180 degrees in relation to the pressure plate.......my middle steel disc did not have an "H". I would think that the pressure plate is balanced, and the "H" is just used during the balancing process, and not necessarily signifying that it is actually heavy at that side, once balanced. The fiber discs are probably not balanced any further, after production...........just my opinion.

    It is the slave cylinder that moves the throw-out bearing. There are seals there that should be replaced..........square type O-rings.........2, if I recall when I did mine.
     
  13. vincenzo

    vincenzo F1 Rookie

    Nov 2, 2003
    3,373
    It was suggested that the splines be lubricated with chassis grease....

    Once installed, the clutch 'friction material' (AKA discs) will wear and circulate within the bellhousing and splines. Grease will attract and hold the friction material within the splines. Makes the lubricant into a grinding compound. Not good.

    I'd suggest 'at most' a silicon spray, lightly applied - with all excess removed.

    It seems to me that this location is best left clean, dry and burr free.

    I'll leave my flack jacket off for this one - I'd like to hear more opinion. Can anybody confirm what the factory(s) do?

    Rgds,
    Vince
     
  14. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    I may be way off here, but since the clutch pack is always spinning, wouldn't dust generally be thrown to the outside of the whole housing by centrifugal force? I'm sure a bit would settle on the shaft eventually, but not much.

    To update, I have cleaned up the shaft and bellhousing, removed the throwout bearing and will be replacing it and the slave cylinder seals. The slave seals seem fine but I've been told they can swell over time and prevent the free motion of the bearing.

    The pilot bearing seems to be fine, so I'm tempted to leave that since it appears to be tricky to remove. I'm going to reinstall the same apparently good clutch, making any adjustments that are necessary in the shims/washers to achieve the pack thickness specified in the workshop manual.

    Thanks to all those that have helped so far, including Tom Jones at SportAuto who is a saint at dealing with inexperienced but well-meaning home mechanics.
     
  15. Frari

    Frari Formula 3

    Nov 5, 2003
    1,194
    brisbane australia
    Full Name:
    tony
    I had a Tr with difficulty changing gears and went through what you have been looking at. my clutch was about 70% worn at the time. Your clutch plates look to have plenty of plate left compared to mine. I fixed linkage alignment and after fiddling with everything we(ferrari Mechanic) and I decided the problem was perhaps slow synchros due to low miles and therefor we changed gear oil and added a racing additive however you must be carefull as some additives can react with copper/brass etc in gearboxes so ensure the additive is ok to use in the older gearbox. I commented on this in a previous thread and gave name of product which is a usa product used by drag racers and racing drivers. Archives may have something on this it was in november 2003 or thereabouts. Antway the gearbox was a lot better. still a little hard when cold but once warm was almost perfect. It just seemed to free up the synchros.
    Hope this helps. If you can not find the thread email me and I will call the dealer and ask for the name for you.
    regards tony
     
  16. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    To update, after much research and frustration and a lot of $$ in tools & parts, the project is progressing. I have rebuilt the slave cylinder, replaced the throw out bearing, replaced the pilot bearing and cleaned everything thoroughly. I am now in the process of reassembling my original clutch. The flywheel is mounted, but before I do the plates, I want to make sure I'm doing the formula correctly for figuring the spacer thickness (the washer between the spacer ring and the middle plate).

    Specifically, if you have the shop manual, letter C in the formula is the one I'm concerned about. There are good instructions for doing A & B and D is a fixed constant range. X is what we're solving for, so I need C. I'm having a hard time from the sideview cutaway diagram in the manual. C appears to be the thickness of the pressure plate at the mounting holes (where it slips over the flywheel studs) plus the thickness of the lockwasher that goes on after the pressure plate.

    Is that right? If not, can someone shed some light on what the proper method of measuring C is?

    At the moment, for the range of D values given, I'm coming up with a spacer that should be between .09" and .102". The spacer I took off was about .07". The best shim I've found to use seems to be a fiber washer which would put me right at .09". I'm a little concerned that the formula seems to want more space between the plates, rather than less as some have suggested.
     
  17. LMPDesigner

    LMPDesigner F1 Rookie
    Silver Subscribed

    Nov 5, 2003
    3,210
    Atlanta Georgia
    I haven't read all of the posts so this may be a repeat but you have another issue to look at here.

    Your flywheel and pressure plate are cooked! Look at all of the blue hot spots in the pictures. I bet that if you run your fingers over the flywheel it will feel somewhat bumpy as you traverse over those "blue elliptical" hot spots. It will not be much-but it will be there.

    This is caused by excessive clutch slippage.

    You should get the flywheel turned true before reassembly and look at either a new intermediate plate of turning that also. (I am not sure that is possible.)
     
  18. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    Had the flywheel turned today. It looks pretty and new and is still within spec, so I will reuse it. Ran about $75 at the local machine shop. They were very nice about educating me about clutch related stuff and some of the machining processes.

    The pressure plate and intermediate plate seem to be beyond help, at least for the machine shops in this area. As a result I am ordering a new clutch pack. I will save my old discs as they have significant life on them if I find next time that the plates aren't burned.

    Also sending out the air filter housing to be stripped and powder coated as they had cracked and started to rust in places.

    Once the whole project is done I plan a detailed writeup to save people some of the headaches I've encountered as a first timer.
     
  19. jselevan

    jselevan Formula 3

    Nov 2, 2003
    1,879
    Charles - I have scanned this thread, and have had the same difficulty in engaging gear while at rest. However, the simplest solution, and one that I am surprised that no one suggested, is to simply bleed the hydraulic clutch slave cylinder at the bell housing. Often air or dirt will enter the system over time. This would have been an easy first approach.

    Now that you are fully disassembled, I would replace the throw-out bearing and, perhaps, the pressure plate with grooves on it.

    Jim S.
     
  20. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    Good and sensible solution, Jim. For the record, this did happen. The car had a major service recently, so of course it was bled when the engine/transaxle was reinstalled. I didn't do the clutch at the same time for financial reasons. Not really any money saved since all you have to do is pull the lower valence and the exhaust again.
     
  21. smithbb

    smithbb Karting

    Jan 27, 2003
    69
    Lancaster, PA
    Full Name:
    Brad Smith
    I know this is a late post but anyone considering the splined lubrication might want to consider a dry option. I was put onto a dry film lubricant by Dow Corning #321. It is extreme temperature -325 to +840 F applies by spray, drys quickly. I've used this for my single lug wheels which have been a significant trial in years past. I'm rebuilding my clutch now and plan on using. As with any lubricant it will wear but it may help for a considerable period and definitely won't attract dust like normal grease. Hope this helps. If you need more info you can contact me.
     
  22. cgperry

    cgperry Formula Junior

    Nov 2, 2003
    506
    Chas SC
    Full Name:
    Charles Perry
    Smith - That's what I ended up using to. A spray-on dry film lubricant with Teflon. Obviously it's too early to tell long-term results, but it certainly went together easily enough.
     

Share This Page