What glue to use for 330GT fuel lid emblem

I am in the process of replacing the fuel lid emblem on a 330GT and am looking for advice on what type of glue to use. It looks like the old glue was more of a "putty" than glue and the emblem isn't really flush on the fuel lid surface, so a putty-like glue seems appropriate. Does anybody have a suggestion on what should be used?
Image Unavailable, Please Login
Image Unavailable, Please Login