What If...you were in MSC's / Ferrari's Position?

Welcome to the board.

just a thing, FA is no easy man to pass. he's no Jenson Button.

 

it won;t be easy true. but then, FA normally pushes himself into making mistakes. Japan last week was a perfect example. he outbraked himself a couple of times. i don't think he needs MS to lead him into a mistake.

 

alonso just needs to circulate and win his Championship.

its someone trying something crazy on him , that alonso needs to
be worried about. Ie , like being intentionally run off the road.
.

 

If it were so simple for MS and FA to change places for the lead on track i'd be dissapointed that it didn't happen more often throughout the entire season.

Honestly there's only a few ways that MS can win the title, either someone is going to be an idiot and try and run FA off the road, He'll crack under the pressure from Ferrari and not finish in 8th or higher (yea right) or his Renault will give him a surprise blow like Michael's Ferrari last weekend which will lead to a slew of badmouthing of his ex-team.

 

Just remember - MS needs to WIN (finish) for anything else to happen.

It's kinda late in his career to change his driving tactics - to try and force the reigning world champion into a mistake.
I'm absolutely sure Flavio has put in a 3rd place motor and told him to motor around and get somewhere between 3rd and 6th.

 

Honestly, i could see Massa taking FA out for the sake of MS and the WDC.
That "anything to help Michael with the championship" quote comes to mind...

Now, not saying i would condone this.....but it wouldn't surprise me.

 

I would not be surprised if they (at Ferrari) joked about it. But I would be very surprised if that happened. I think MS was being honest when he said he would not want to win that way. I personally am hoping Sato takes FA out by accident . For that to happen FA needs to be at the back of the grid

 

German newspapers are speculating about it:

If MS does another Damon Hill/JV on FA, then he'll risk to get stranded himself. So that doesn't really work since he has to win.

If Massa tries to run into FA, Ferrari risks loosing the constructors title to Renault.

The newspaper went on to speculate about Ralf being used as a weapon to take out FA, but I doubt that the brotherly love goes that far.

What nobody talks about: The Red Bulls. There is no love lost between DC and MS, so I don't think Dave will do the dirty deed, but what about Dornboos? He still probably harbors some dark thoughts. Should be interesting.

 

You are right! I forgot about Dornboos. Any one that takes FA out will be in the spot light next year. It could make for an interesting story line through out the 2007.

 

good points Andreas. i doubt about that ralf thing tho. he publicly said he's not on good terms with Michael. but then...dornboos and FA. hehe...after all, Dornboos is w/out a ride next season. well, virtually he is, pending on the new testing rules.

lets not forget that BS will monopolise the industry next season. so, a 3rd driver is rarely needed. plus, he has a very strong history with FA. i'm keeping my fingers crossed. oh yea.. we also have good 'ol Sato

 

I would race a good race and what happens happens.

Anyone "taking out" Fernando would be stupid.

It would have been great to see MS make an amazing come-back this year for the WDC but he had some bum luck in Japan.... so what, it's a freekin race/sport.... MS will be just fine.

I am actually really looking forward to next years F1 season, with everything new and the top drivers changed around it should really be exciting to watch.

 

Most likely scenario... MS runs 2nd to Felipe early going, as they assess reliability of Renault. If Fernando drops out, then Felipe will have some sort of "problem", allowing MS to win it all. As long as Fernando is in the points, it will be a Ferrari 1-2, w/ Felipe getting the win in front of his home fans and carrying mojo into 2007 (not what Kimi wants to see though).

Cheers

 

Ferrari 1 - 2!

The rest will be left to Renault and Alonso!

 

lets just hope so

 

You're absolutely right--that is silly. I follow your logic for winning a championship right up until the part about letting your competitor pass you. Don't forget that, in order to take the Driver's Championship, Michael needs to win and have Alonso post a goose egg. So playing "Tag, you're it!" all race long will only hand the titles to Alonso and Renault.

 

I would agree with you on the logic of this type of action/instruction by Flavio, but key is will emotional Alonso follow instructions from his soon to be ex boss?

I think you will see a very clean race on the part of Ferrari. They may follow through on their response to Renault as to "blocking", but I do not see any intentional actions to wreck anybody.

Interesting thought about Dornboos, but his position/reputation in F1 long term is probably more important to him than an Alonso payback.

An anti-climatic race.

 

Our best chance... 2 words:

SA-TO

 

First off all, I think taking out anybody is underhanded and dumb. When Senna took out Prost in 1990, it was stupid. Samething when MS did what he did to Damon Hill and later tried the stunt on JV, another bad move. You think Jim Clark or Juan Manuel Fangio would ever try a stunt like that?

The championship wasn't lost at Japan, it was lost during the course of the season. If Alonso were to go out, I hope it is by mechanical failure and not some idiot running into him.

I hope MS wins the race and Massa follows him home, I just don't want to see the championship decided by taking out your rival. Ferrari still has a great opportunity to take the Constructors and I hope MS wins to close out his career with a win, but not at the expense of taking out a rival.

 

It looks like MS winning the WDC is a very low probability scenario. I think the best that Michael can do is close out his brilliant career with a win.

On the constructor's side it is difficult as well, we need a Ferrari 1-2 and Renault to finish no better than 4th and 6th. I think Alonso is going to haulhimself into the podium anyway so this scenario looks doubtful.

 

Aha!! I've got it.

Renault tells FA to "lay back" and just get his one point.

Alonso tools around in 5th beind Fisi in 4th.
(Schumi, Massa, Button, Fisi, FA)

He gets bored and starts to think about his parc ferme kung-fooey hustle carnival dance.

He gets brain fade and whacks into the back of Fisi.

Game, set, match. Ta-da!




Except that Renault *must* get on the podium if Ferrari pull a 1-2. If Ferrari garners 18 points, Renault finishing 4th and 5th would net 9 points, the constructor points would tie at 204 each, and it would go by 9 red wins to 8 blues. Renault will likely care more about that than the #1 that FA would take to McLaren anyway.

Renault might actually prefer to keep Alonso in 4th behind Fisi, holding off Button and Kubica.
Nope: Never mind. If FA finishes 2nd, Fisi doesn't need any points at all to wrap up the WCC.

 

One thing I would not do for sure if I was in MS place is to cheat on my wife. If she took half, I would end up talking to myself and hanging out with Paul McCartney.